Monday, October 16, 2006

Flip Flop on Natuna D-Alpha

In less than one month, government officers made flip-flop and conflicting statements on the status of ExxonMobil & Pertamina's contract to develop the massive gas reserves called Natuna D-Alpha project.

Today, both energy minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro and BPMigas chairman Kardaya Warnika stated that the Natuna PSC had been automatically terminated in January 2005. Few weeks ago, both officers stated that give time to Exxon & Pertamina until January 2007. In between, both guys also stated that Exxon may still operate the gas block but with brand new contract.
On the other hand, ExxonMobil which controls 76% shares in Natuna D-Alpha (Pertamina 24%) insisted that the contract is valid until 2009. (FYI, Pertamina initially owned 50% shares in Natuna D-Alpha. But somehow Pertamina divested 26% few years ago, and nobody raised the question, why? I could understand if the divestment is considered a big mistake, especially with the sky-high energy price in recent years)
Anyway, back to the Natuna legal battle, it's clear that both parties have different interpretation of the contract itself. Article II.2.2 of Natuna PSC amended in 1995 stated that if contractors (Exxon & Natuna) failed to come up with clear commitment before January 2005, the contract shall automatically terminated. Exxon claimed that it's letter dated December 2004 to BPMigas confirming the commitment to develop Natuna has been enough to secure the first two year extension, which means until January 2007. Article II.2.3 also stated that if one of the parties (BPMigas or contractor) asking for extension after the first two year of extension to further confirm the project, it's deemed obliged to approve additional second two-year extension (until 2009).
Government claimed that the contract has not been terminated unilaterally, but automatically. It means, government should provide proofs that contractor (Exxon & Pertamina) failed to meet the requirements in the contract. So far, no such proofs available that legally convincing. But Kardaya seems to believe that government is in strong position even if Exxon challenge that in international arbitrary. People that familiar to oil & gas business doubt though. "It's gonna be the next Karaha Bodas," he said.
What if government think that Indonesia managed to postpone hundreds of million dollar fine of Karaha Bodas case? Well, let's read brand new flip-flop statements in the newspaper in the coming weeks or so.
But the first statements, maturity of contract in 2007, has completely different legal consequences, i.e. government acknowledging Exxon's commitment made in December 2004 and the 2-year extension accordingly. Meanwhile if government claim the contract had been terminated automatically in Jan 2005, it has to come up with proofs to support that and probably a stupid question: Why government said before that the contract would mature in Jan 07? Or another stupid question: What's happened in the last two years? Where are all these guys?
I try to take positive leasons out of this. Suppose that gas price stays the same like 5 years ago, nobody would care about Natuna D-Alpha, because it's just too costly to develop. Now that government want to renegotiate for better terms, that's good. But we have to do it right. Some people try to blame Soeharto or BJ Habibie for the contract given to Exxon. Partly true because we always forget to protect ourselves from future ups-and-downs in contracts with smarter guys. Meaning, we have to learn to be smart in negotiations, articles by articles, paragraph by paragraph, and word by word.

Labels: , , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Friday, September 22, 2006

Habibie's Memoir: Questions

Suppose that president Habibie didn't call miliary commander Wiranto to ask the general to stay in his position, would Wiranto tell Habibie about the 'existence' of Kostrad troops around State Palace and Habibie's residence? Why Wiranto didn't file a report before Habibie's call? Is there any convincing proofs about Prabowo's move? Why Habibie prefer to believe in Wiranto than Prabowo? Those are questions that remain unanswered in BJ Habibie's recently published book, Decisive Seconds.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Wednesday, September 20, 2006

Habibie's Decisive Seconds: Book Excerpts

Former president BJ Habibie's memoir, titled Decisive Seconds, tells us some interesting events about the transition of power from Soeharto, how he kick out general Prabowo---that time Kostrad Commander and still Soeharto's son-in-law, and how Soeharto rejected his appeals to meet, Kompas reported.

"This is an abasement. You fired me as Kostrad Commander?" Lt Gen Prabowo asked. "Not fired, replaced," Habibie replied.
"Why? I want to protect the President."
"That's the task of President's Security Forces with direct responsibility to Military Commander, not your job..."
"What kind of President are you? On behalf of my father's and my father-in-law's name, please give me three more months as Kostrad commander."
"No. Before the sun goes down, all Kostrad forces should be under the new commander."
That was the tense dialog between Prabowo & Habibie on May 22, 1998, less than 24 hours after Habibie sworn in as president.
The dialog was stopped when ret lt general Sintong Panjaitan cut the dialog and said...General, The President has no more time, leave the room...
Earlier that day, 06.10, Habibie called Gen Wiranto and asked him to stay in his position as TNI Commander. Wiranto reported to Habibie the movement of Kostrad forces around the State Palace and Habibie's residence at Patra Kuningan, South Jakarta.
At 07.30, commander general of Special Forces (Kopassus) Maj Gen Muchdi met Habibie with the letter from Gen (Ret) AH Nasution asking Habibie to promote Gen Subagyo HS as TNI Commander and Prabowo as Army's Chief of Staff (KSAD).

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, September 16, 2006

Habibie's Decisive Seconds

Former president BJ Habibie is about to launch his memoir titled Decisive Seconds: Indonesia's Long Journey to Democracy. The 549-page book is based on Habibie's diary especially during the transition from Soeharto regime in what he called decisive moments that changed the course of the nation.

"Policies that I made have been very important and couldn't be influenced by anybody. If I followed the noises that try to influence the decisions, may be we have a different nation now, could be a socialist Indonesia or Islamic country, not the united Indonesia republic," Habibie explained part of the book.
He promised the book contains facts and significant events he wrote in details about the early days of reform movement in the country.
Habibie raised to power as Indonesia's third president following Soeharto's decision to step down after months of mass and violent protests. Habibie failed to keep his power after lost the first democratic election in 1999 after decades of authoritarian rules of Soekarno & Soeharto.
Wish Habibie, a tecno-minded personality, publish his full diary in a blog. His book would be a good reading though.
Full of energy, I remember Habibie always said (when I cover technology beat in my early years as journalist) that he admired both Soekarno & Soeharto even though that time no minister would openly stated admiration on Soekarno (Soeharto hate that!).
It was Soekarno, the first president and father of former president Megawati Soekarnoputri, who encouraged him to study in Germany (aerospace) and Soeharto brought him home to be one of his 'golden boy'.
He gained stronger influence on Soeharto's economic policies in early 1990s and credited him for Habibienomics to make a contrast to Widjojonomics (school of liberal economic thoughts) brought in by Prof Widjojo Nitisastro (and his Berkeley Mafia) that ruled the country for many decades.
A colorful personality, a small group of journalist (three of us) used to interview him at his office with desk full of aircraft models. It's difficult to stop him explaining things. He could explain hard-to-digest issues to legislators till 3AM and all of us still love to listen.
But his projects failed to take-off as what he dreamed of. The aircraft industry (IPTN) has been crashed since 1997. We used to make our own version of IPTN as the abbreviation of Industri Penerima Tamu Negara (Industry to Host State Guests) because almost all state guests were arranged to visit the aircraft assembling plant in Bandung, West Java. The shipping industry (PT PAL) also sinked.
But, I think these are not part of the book. And would be more interesting to read the decisive seconds in early days of reform, including how he prevented military coup d'etat.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Friday, August 11, 2006

Special Economic Zones: From KAPET to KEKI

We love abbreviations. During the last years of Soeharto regime, we knew KAPET (Kawasan Ekonomi Terpadu) or Integrated Economic Zone. Now, we have another name, Kawasan Ekonomi Khusus Indonesia (KEKI) or Special Economic Zones. Would it make any difference in attracting investment?

Soeharto administration had established 13 KAPETs with beautiful names. They are Bandar Aceh Darussalam (Aceh), Khatulistiwa (West Kalimantan), Sasamba (East Kalimantan), Batulicin (South Kalimantan), DAS Kakab (Central Kalimantan), Manado Bitung (North Sulawesi), Bukari (South East Sulawesi), Parepare (South Sulawesi), Bima (West Nusa Tenggara), Mbay (East Nusa Tenggara), Seram (Maluku), and Biak (Papua).
Government even established a website dedicated to promote KAPETs at www.kapet.org. As far as I remember, many times Soeharto regime and then followed by BJ Habibie administration, promised to give incentives to those who want to invest in KAPETs. I checked the organization's website on the incentive topic, unfortunately I found no information. Then I tried to click 'government support', similar results, big zero.
That's probably the reason why I never read news about major investment in these KAPETs in the last few years.
Early this year, government promised to revitalize KAPETs, and as usual, claimed to review the possibility to give fiscal incentives on top of custom and import duty incentives available at the moment. That's the latest until all of a sudden everybody switches the gear to KEKI with the same-old-promises.
The only difference is that KEKI could be everywhere, open for initiative from local or regional administrations as long as they could meet the 12 requirements (to be drafted, no details yet). That's why Jakarta Governor Sutiyoso entered the KEKI game today saying his administration is ready to have Jakarta as one of the KEKIs, following other areas like Batam, Bintan & Karium in Riau Island Province.
Well, I could only hope that this time government really deliver its promises. I can't stand to have another name a decade later with empty promises again. We really need investment to create more jobs and improve our people's quality of life.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Friday, June 09, 2006

The Fight for License to Squeeze

In early 1990s, Indonesia's investment coordinating board (BKPM) offered a program called One Stop Service to shorten lengthy bureaucrazy in processing business licenses. The idea was to make everything easy for investor when they want to start business here.

Bold idea actually. Imagine that as an investor you have to deal with hundreds of government institutions right from the cabinet to a village chief (kepala desa) before you could really put in the money. And along the way, most of the time, you have to spend huge amount of money to get these licenses. Land and building construction license, license to employ expatriates, to tap underground water, electricity, telephone line, noise license, etc. The One Stop Service was a mere dream. None of these various institutions want to give away their authority to give licenses because that's the main source of income for the low-paid state officers.
People thougt political reform could change that. In fact, after the downfall of Soeharto, the idea of One Stop Service for investors at BPKM have been repeatedly discussed. But Big Zero!
That's also the case with the management of state-owned enterprises (SOEs). Soeharto gave authority to different ministries depend on what business the SOE involved in. So all the state-owned plantation companies were under the ministry of agriculture, telcos under the transportation and telecommunication ministry, and so forth.
But then Habibie established a new ministry of SOE to manage all these SOEs.
To be continued...

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, June 06, 2006

Just outsmart Berkeley Mafia!

A group of economists appeared in a seminar titled 40 Years of Mafia Berkeley vs Alternative Ideas of Indonesia's economic development, yesterday. They're former chief economic minister Rizal Ramli (under Abdurrahman Wahid administration), Kwik Kian Gie (former chief economic minister under Wahid, replaced by Ramli), Ichsanuddin Noorsy, Revrisond Baswir, and Sri Edi Swasono (son-in-law of first Vice President Mohammad Hatta). Guest speaker was Jeffrey Winters (Northwestern University).

It was an unbalanced seminar as none of what they called Mafia Berkeley delivered arguments, no exchange of arguments actually, it's a kind of monologue of ideas, it's like bad idea vs good idea. That was not an academic exercise of thoughts. The speakers believe the alternative ideas they delivered are the only public goods. So that's a seminar with so many personal issues at stakes.
The speakers even failed to explain or acknowledged what they did and didn't while they have power in their hands to drive the economic policies into what they believe the right way and change the course of the nation.
Nor did they explain what's wrong or right during BJ Habibie's strong influence in the economy of the early 1990s. So don't expect them explaining what's right and wrong during the early years of Berkeley Mafia.
How we explain the massive debt settlement of 1998-2001 during which the government's domestic debt jumped to Rp700 trillion (US$80 billion) to bailout corporate debts of the like Texmaco Group's Rp30 trillion, Salim's Rp60 trillion, Sjamsul Nursalim's Rp28 trillion, or Sinar Mas's Rp14 trillion?
It were Soeharto's last year, Habibie, Wahid and Megawati administration's economic team who endorsed the debt settlement through agreements like the Master of Settlement and Acquisition Agreement (MSAA), MRNIA, or Debt Acknowledgement Acts (APU). How we explain the problems at state-owned enterprises like Habibie's aircraft company PT IPTN (now Dirgantara Indonesia), Garuda Indonesia, PLN, Pertamina and so forth?
I believe the Mafia Berkeley had committed some wrongdoings, just like the other mafias of Habibie's, Ginandjar's, Rizal Ramli's or Kwik Kian Gie's.
Look at this. Rizal Ramli and Kwik Kian Gie as the coordinating minister for the economy during Wahid administration had the chance to fix the lousy debt settlements with Salim, Nursalim, or even Sinivasan's Texmaco. But they were hopeless, not because of the Berkeley Mafia, but simply because of the complicated and fluid political situation aftermath of the 1998 reform.
I believe in one thing...when it comes to liberalization, globalization, privatization...they're all political decisions, not just economic models. There are a lot of aspects of the society at play. Simply blaming the mafi is just like you had a headache in the morning and keep blaming the traffic jam on your way to office for your bad day.
What's amazing is the acknowledgement of this alternative group of how powerful the Berkeley Mafia so it could survive almost 40 years and still in the driving seat of the economy even though none of them hold official position in the cabinet. I must say this Mafia Berkeley is so smart to control this big country four decades so far and may be more.
Other mafia groups might have to learn of how Mafia Berkeley keep its power. An old advise, if you really want to beat the members of this mafia, outsmart them all! All you have to do is to convince all the stakeholders of this nation to get their full attention on your alternative ideas. People are smart enough to make decision, they could analyze what's wrong and right with Berkeley Mafia and what's wrong or right with your ideas! Don't get mad, get even!

Labels: , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, May 11, 2006

The trials we missed, The winners takes all

It's just inches away for former president Soeharto to be a free man. The cabinet has prepared the presidential decree for a full rehabilitation for him and the first president Soekarno as the sweetener. In fact, as reported by Tempointeraktif.com, Attorney General's Office had lifted the overseas travel ban on Soeharto. So, he could get first-class medical treatment overseas very soon. I do agree with Koran Tempo's editorial today that insists a trial for Soeharto and after that the president may issue an abolition or amnesty.
But I do realize that's a daylight dreaming especially with the current political structure, a result of Soeharto's clever moves. Most people still in the believe that Soeharto always pretend to be a sick person whenever prosecutors try to have him stands trial. But even if he's mentally healthy, as I believe that's the case, the power structure has been weak enough to make it happen. And this also applies to those banking criminals. Why?
Soeharto's aides were so clever to endorse the political liberalization aftermath the boss downfall. The reformists blindly campaigned for a full liberalization without ever calculating the impacts on their movements, especially on Soeharto and his cronies. Without limitation on number of political parties entitled to contest the 1999 election, the nation was stunned with almost 45 political parties registered to contest.
The New Order regime smartly invested in establishing political parties, not to resume the power, but mainly to prevent one single party win the election with clear majority votes. The strategy worked pretty well. PDI-P came out as the winner but only with 33% seats in the parliament. Golkar was the second with 20%-something, while others well below 20%. That was the first victory for Soeharto followed by the second when Megawati lost the presidential election to Abdurrahman Wahid. Golkar clearly was behind Wahid's win. Wahid appointed Marzuki Darusman, a Golkar executive, as the Attorney General. The then Golkar chairman Akbar Tanjung won the election of the House Speaker.
On the surface, the new administration led by Wahid and Megawati was seen as a strong coalition of nationalists. Wahid did start the prosecution on Soeharto and named him a suspect with corruption charges. Soeharto didn't show up in the first hearing in August 3, 2000 and missed two consecutive hearings in August 31 and September 14, 2000. Two weeks later, judges rejected the trial and released Soeharto from city arrest status.
Wahid once sent Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (that time as mining and energy minister) to negotiate the return of Soeharto family's wealth (Time magazine once reported the amount) to the state. Soeharto's oldest daughter Siti Hardijanti Rukmana (Mbak Tutut) admitted the meeting with Yudhoyono that time.
But then the coalition broke up with shameful impeachment of Wahid supported immensely by Golkar, PPP, other parties, and most importantly the silent support from Indonesian military.
Megawati replaced Wahid and Hamzah Haz (former minister under BJ Habibie administration, then chairman of PPP) was the elected VP. We had new coalition of PDI-P, Golkar and PPP; plus the military. In such a coalition, Megawati administration was hopeless when it comes to Soeharto's trial. Megawati found a new friend, Akbar Tanjung and his Golkar Party without which she wouldn't survive till the 2004 election. Her administration revived the investigation in June 2002, but Soeharto's medical team managed to stop the trial when they announced Soeharto's permanent brain disorder.
In the 2004 election runoff, politicians 'managed' to impose stricter requirements for political parties which entitled to contest. Megawati lost the election despite formal support from Golkar which came out as the winner of legislative election. Military, despite its out-of-politic claim, was in fact behind Megawati's main contender, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, a retired army general. Megawati tried to boost her popularity with a promise to bring Soeharto to court, but people just didn't buy. Critics on Yudhoyono's partner, Jusuf Kalla (key Golkar figure and businessman), were also ignored. SBY-JK won anonimously the election. Few months in office, Yudhoyono explicitly told public that he would prefer to forget the past and move on with the new chapter. And last year he paid a visit to Soeharto when the former boss was rushed to a hospital. VP Jusuf Kalla and other political figures did the same. They echoed the call to put an end to Soeharto's trial. This week, almost all of the national leaderships join the chorus and this time Soeharto would likely score the biggest victory. Freedom! Rehabilitation! Abolition! Whatever.
Soeharto's crony capitalists have scored their own victories at the time of reform euphoria in the 1998-1999 period. This is the period when Soeharto's loving 'pupil' BJ Habibie lead the transition administration. Habibie's administration signed the famous Master of Settlement and Acquisition Agreement (MSAA) with bank owners who committed banking crimes i.e. the violation of legal lending limit (LLL).
Under the MSAA, Habibie's administration agreed not to bring the bankers to court for their respective crimes as long as they payback the amount of bailout loans. These bankers agreed with condition that they don't have to pay in cash. Government said OK, cash and nearcash or other assets that could be sold.
Salim, the owner of Bank Central Asia (BCA), then paid few trillions of rupiah in cash and shares in 107 companies to pay around 60 trillion debts. Sjamsul Nursalim (Gajah Tunggal) agreed to pay one trillion rupiah in cash and Rp27 trillion in assets. Soeharto's golf buddy Mohammad 'Bob' Hasan and Soeharto's cousin Sudwikatmono also signed the similar MSAAs. Government have sold out almost all of these pledged assets at heavy discounts, some bought by the debtors themselves through special purpose vehicle companies established overseas.
Other bank owners signed different forms of MSAA such as MRNIA or APU, which were basically the same i.e. exchange the freedom with payments of debts. Some says these crony capitalists invested a lot in some political parties to get these agreements, something extremely difficult to proof. And these agreements were the saviour for the banking criminals, bullets proof!
These are the trials that we missed so much. And these supposedly crime suspects are the winners that takes all, including our dream for justice. The least Yudhoyono could do, may be, is telling public his negotiations with Soeharto family during Wahid's administration to return the wealths to the state.
PS: A banker from Switzerland sent greetings to Soeharto. He asked me whether it's true that Soeharto is free to go overseas. Unfortunately he didn't tell me why he raised that particular issue!

Labels: , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, April 29, 2006

Danareksa's poor performance

State-owned investment bank PT Danareksa (Persero) reported net loss of Rp182 billion (US$18.5 million) for financial year 2005 against net profit of Rp32.5 billion the previous year.
According to its financial report published Saturday (April 29), Danareksa booked total revenue of Rp225 billion, dropped sharply from Rp416 billion in 2004.
Why? The company recorded net loss of Rp18 billion in securities trading against net profit of Rp107 billion in 2004. The company's revenue from services also reduced significantly. Not to mention the heavy drop in revenue from issuance fee from Rp53 billion to Rp3.6 billion.
One may argue that Danareksa has huge debts. But the company's interests payment actually decreased last year to Rp128 billion (against Rp143 billion).
Bad loans chanelled in the past also cost the company huge allowance of losses at Rp111 billion. But even without that, Danareksa would still in red.
So, it is a combination of poor loans management in the past and poor performance of its operation last year. Danareksa's president Lin Che Wei, a confidante of state-owned enterprise minister Sugiharto, might has better explanation on why public will not get the dividend from the company this year.
An analyst, and one of the panelists at the presidential candidate debate in 2004 election, Che Wei surely has to proof that he has the capability to turn the state-owned company around.
With total assets of almost US$200 million, people can't afford to live with the loss-making state-owned companies.
Minister Sugiharto moved his office to Danareksa building since late last year for undisclosed reasons. He occupy the office previously for Danareksa's CEO. As a result, Danareksa had refurbished and built new office for Che Wei. Just like when then SOE Minister Tanri Abeng (during BJ Habibie administration) moved to Indosat building.
So, the problem is right in front of Sugiharto's nose. Should be easier to fix. At least the CEO could have been easier to make appointments with the minister, right?

Labels: , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, March 21, 2006

Jakarta subway, another 30 years of discussion

It's just ten days away for Indonesia government to decide, whether to accept Japan's offer to finance the long-awaited mass rapid transportation system (MRT) to be built in super-crowded Jakarta. March 31 is the deadline as Japan will start the new fiscal year.
Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JIBC) has repeatedly offer low-interest rate loans, this time 0.4% over 40 years of payment and 10 years of grace period. I would say the offer is lot better than the recently issued US$1 billion global bonds which bears 7.75% interest per annum.
Jakarta Governor Sutiyoso seems want to close his 10-year tenure (next year) with something spectaculer to remember. So he wrote president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono recently asking government's decision on the MRT project. (This one is probably more important than Sutiyoso's proposal to create a Megapolitan Administration)
He doubted the plan of some state-owned enterprises to takeover the project. "Even we can't build good schools building," he said with cynism.
That's not the first statement of Sutiyoso. I remember back in 2001, Sutiyoso once claimed the construction of MRT project to be started that year at the cost of US$1.75 billion and would absorb 60,000 workers. He should make this happen now.
Three years ago, JBIC agreed to provide US$767.66 million funding for the MRT system at higher interest rate of 0.95%. So, if Sutiyoso was right with the latest offer of 0.4%, this one could significantly cut almost half the interest payments over 30 years time.
I wonder if government could make decision this time. But to my surprise, government rejected Japan's offer on disagreement over terms of the loans (tied loans) and Indonesia's demand to have 75% local content in the project.
Fourteen years ago, when I was a reporter for technology beat, then minister for research and technology BJ Habibie (former president) was the one who heavily supported the country's long-awaited mass rapid transport system. I wrote many articles about the subway system many times only to be upset over and over. Even some of them with exact timetable that the MRT would be in operation by 2000.
I agree 100% with the MRT system, probably due to personal experience with Underground in London, UK or Bay Area Rapid Transport (BART) in Bay Area, San Francisco, USA. That's why I never fed up imagining Jakarta would have such system some day.
But, my goodness, 30 years have passed, we're keep talking about it. That's why Jakartans love to call MRT as a Masih Rapat Terus (Still Under Discussion) project.
Imagine that, the idea was first floated in the 1970s and later during the administration of governor Surjadi Soedirdja, was last postponed after the financial crisis in 1997.
Transportation experts have repeatedly said that the MRT was one of the most effective solutions to tackling chronic traffic congestion in the capital, although they also said it would be extremely expensive.
Other observers say the city's messy underground sewer, power and telecommunications networks, its unstable soil structure and its recurrent flooding problems could turn any underground project into an engineering nightmare. The engineering fears are real given that Jakarta is basically a flood plain but Bangkok has been able to do it.
Imagine the congestion in the capital when the construction starts. But I think people would not mind at all, say for three years, as long as they know exactly MRT could make their life better off.
So what's the problem then?
Well, back in 1994, Habibie signed a memorandum of understanding with two Japanese companies, Sumitomo and Itochu, to build the MRT.
In 1995, when Surjadi was the governor, he signed the MoU with Japan European Group which consisted of PT Citra Lamtorogung (controlled by Siti Hardiyanti Rukmana, former president Soeharto's eldest daughter), PT Bakrie Investindo (controlled by Aburizal Bakrie, currently the coordinating minister for people's welfare),Itochu, and Ferrostaal (Germany).
Other investors worth mentioned are Ciputra Group, Lippo Group, Bukaka Group (partly owned by VP Jusuf Kalla's family) and Suthamtabie (a company owned by the family of Habibie).
I guess, as long as government can't settle the issue of who would be the investors in this project, we should wait few more decades, or even it will never come.
This time, government turned down Japan's offer for funding on local content issue, in which Indonesia government demanded 75% of the value of the project should be provided by local companies. It means that we have to wait 30 more years to really have MRT in place.
Others said intensive lobby from automotive producers may also block the MRT project. But if they book lower car sales in Jakarta, like in the last three months, blame the traffic!

Labels: , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, March 09, 2006

Freeport Debacle: Money Talks

Kompas published a very good photograph of Amien Rais (former Assembly Speaker) holding the shoulder of Ginandjar Kartasasmita (former minister under Soeharto and BJ Habibie regimes). The photo was taken yesterday when Amien paid a courtessy call to Ginandjar, the chairman of Regional Representatives Council (DPD) as part of the former's roadshow to gather support for to shutdown the giant mining operation of PT Freeport Indonesia.
But Amien seems soften his stance yesterday. Instead of shutting down the operation, he echoed Ginandjar's proposal to ask government increase Indonesia's shares in Freeport to 25%. Indonesia government currently holds 9.36% shares of Freeport.
Amien said renegotiating Freeport's working contract, awarded in 1991 when Ginandjar was still the energy and mining minister under Soeharto regime, would give a bigger slice of revenue to Indonesia and Papua people. Sounds good.
How to finance the acquisition of another 16% shares of Freeport at more than US$1.5 billion? Well, for sure government has no money to do that. "But we could buy the shares bit by bit using the divident from Freeport," Ginandjar argues. This logic would need more than 10 years, I guess.
The fastest way, off course, give it to private sector and state-owned enterprises through leverage buy-out, let say. Companies like Bumi Resources and Energi Mega Persada, both are linked to Aburizal Bakrie (close friend of Ginandjar and Amien's favourite PAN Chairman Sutrisno Bachir).
Look at Amien Rais' logic. He said Freeport conducted three crimes. They are environmental problem, tax evasion, and looting.

Labels: , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, February 14, 2006

Lippo Karawaci profit increased 23%

Listed property giant under Lippo Group, PT Lippo Karawaci Tbk reported net profit of Rp358.94 billion last year (12 months) or a 23% growth from Rp292.9 billion in 2004.
According to its audited financial report published today the company booked 19.8% growth in total sales to Rp2 trillion last year against Rp1.67 trillion in 2004. The company then recorded gross profit Rp999.2 billion (around US$100 million) and operating profit of Rp536 billion.
Lippo Karawaci completed the restructuring in 2004 resulting in total assets of Rp6.23 trillion as of December 2005. The company is owned by Greatmind Investment Ltd (15.44%), Pacific Asia Holdings Ltd (13.95%), Capital Bloom Investment Ltd (7.76%), and public investors (62.85%).
Several former ministers sits as commissioners at Lippo Karawaci. They are Surjadi Sudirja (former minister of internal affairs under Abdurrahman Wahid administration), Tanri Abeng (former minister of state-owned enterprises under BJ Habibie admnistration), and Agum Gumelar (former minister of transportation under Megawati Soekarnoputri administration). Both Surjadi and Agum are senior military figures retired as lieutnant generals.
Bank loans in the company jumped from Rp492 billion to Rp1 trillion last year with Raiffeisen Zentralbank Oesterreich AG (Singapore) as the biggest creditor (US$50 million), followed by Bank Niaga (Rp181 billion) and the affiliated Bank Lippo (Rp112 billion).

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Friday, February 10, 2006

Freeport Fracas

Indonesia government steps up pressure on PT Freeport Indonesia. This time Vice President Jusuf Kalla disclosed a plan to investigate Freeport's operation, including its gold transaction. Kalla, who is also Golkar Party Chairman, was suspicious on Freeport's gold and copper transaction saying the country should have received revenues three times of what the company actually paid.
Last month, House Speaker Agung Laksono, who is also deputy chairman of Golkar Party, rejected pressures from NGOs to close down Freeport.
Former Assembly Speaker Amien Rais who has been the main spokes person of anti-Freeport movement in the last few weeks, successfully mounts pressure through Partai Amanat Nasional (National Mandate Party), the party Amien co-found. He even urged government to close down Freeport's operation. According to Amien, and this seems to be accommodated by government, Freeport conducted three major crimes: Environmental problems, production and reserves data cover up, and unfair revenue sharing.
The government-sanctioned team would likely focus its investigation on Amien's accusations. I'm not surprised if the government wouldn't investigate the corruption involving the military officers. But why Amien put the military corruption issue behind?
Forget about that. Suppose that the team will find irregularities, what's gonna happen? The weakest punishment might be fines, rehabilitation program, community development program an so forth. The strongest could be kicking Freeport out of the mine completely.
Whatever would be the recommendation, all have its price. In the last 52 weeks of trading, Freeport's share price hit the lowest in May 2005 at US$31.52 and the highest last month at US$65. Recently the FCX price dropped to US$56.83 (Thursday, February 9). I'm not sure whether the political pressure in Indonesia had something to do with the significant drop of almost 15% in Freeport's share price.
Those who want to buy Freeport Indonesia or Indocopper Investama (100% owned by Freeport McMoRan, 9% shares in Freeport Indonesia) clearly expects more pressure. So many parties have interests in acquiring Freeport. But if Freeport would be to difficult to be acquired (including by force, considering US influence in the country), Indocopper would be OK.
The divestment of Freeport shares is a complex issue. The working contract signed in 1991, paragraph 24 states that FCX is obligated to divest 51 percent of the shares in Freeport and to be fully complied within 20 years. During the first stage, between 1991 and 2001, Freeport was obliged to divest 10 percent and to be followed with additional 41 percent between 2001 and 2011. Ironically, in the same paragraph, FCX is also given the escape clause.
In July 2004, FCX was given a maximum of 180 days until the end of January 2005 to carry out the divestment. But nothing's happened. Even president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono failed to pave the way for divestment when he was energy minister under Abdurrahman Wahid administration.
How about Indocopper?
In November 2004, Tempo magazine reported that four financial institutions were prepared to back up the Papua government in its bid to purchase Indocopper. It was the late Papua governor JP Solosa who raised the issue. But he didn't mention the financiers.
Indocopper is still a mystery. Aburizal Bakrie (owner of Bakrie Group, currently coordinating minister for people's affairs) disclosed to prosecutors in 1998 that he got the approval to acquire Freeport through Indocopper from energy department on December 30, 1991. Director General for Mining Kosim Gandataruna signed the approval letter. Former energy minister Ginandjar Kartasasmita (currently chairman of Regional Council at People's Consultative Assembly) has been the target of accusations on profiting from the Bakrie-Freeport deal.
Bakrie claimed he bought Freeport at US$228 million (US$55 million in cash and US$173 million loans from Chemical Bank, USA). Six years later, Bakrie Group made US$315 million prior to 1997 crisis when PT Bakrie & Brothers and PT Bakrie Investindo decided to sell ther shares 49% and 2% respectively in PT Indocopper Investama to PT Nusamba Minerals, a subsidiary of Nusamba Group controlled by Mohammad 'Bob' Hasan, Soeharto's golf buddy. Indocopper owned 9.4% shares in PT Freeport Indonesia. Freeport McMoRan (FCX) also owned 49% shares in Indocopper that time.
Initially then president director of Bakrie & Brothers Tanri Abeng (former minister of state-owned enterprises under BJ Habibie and currently president commissioner of listed PT Telkom Tbk) claimed that all payments from Nusamba would be in cash. But according to FCX report, Nusamba only paid US$61.6 million in cash and financed the remaining US$253.4 million of the $315.0 million purchase price with a variable-rate commercial loan from a syndicate of commercial banks, including JP Morgan Chase Bank as agent, which was to mature in March 2002.
FCX guaranteed the Nusamba loan for the purpose of continuing minority Indonesian ownership of PT Freeport Indonesia. FCX also agreed to lend to Nusamba any amounts required to cover any shortfalls between the interest payments due on the commercial loan and dividends received by Nusamba from PT Indocopper Investama.
Through December 31, 2002, FCX loaned Nusamba US$68.9 million to cover such shortfalls and charged to expense US$7.3 million of this amount because the loans exceeded Nusamba’s initial cash investment.
In discussions shortly after December 31, 2001, Nusamba informed FCX that it did not expect to be able to repay the bank loan or FCX’s loan at maturity, which would obligate FCX to pay the bank loan.
On February 27, 2002, FCX repaid the bank loan as provided for under the terms of its credit facilities and acquired Nusamba’s ownership in PT Indocopper Investama. For accounting purposes, the transactions were deemed effective as of December 31, 2001. As a result of FCX’s payment of the Nusamba bank loan, FCX’s ownership interest in PT Freeport Indonesia increased to 90.6 percent from 85.9 percent. Indonesia government owns 9.4% shares in the company.
Last year, state-owned mining company PT Aneka Tambang Tbk announced its plan to acquire government' shares in Freeport. State-Owned Enterprises Minister Sugiharto had pledged support for Antam's plan. The company appointed HSBC to give advice on the acquisition.
Antam was prioritizing the 9.36% stake of PT FI owned by the government rather than the 9.36% stake held by Indocopper, even though both options will be considered as part of the financial due diligence. Since then, no news from Antam until last week's story published in Bisnis Indonesia that a merger between two Bakrie affiliated companies (PT Bumi Resources Tbk and PT Energi Mega Persada Tbk) might be followed with acquisition of Freeport.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Monday, January 09, 2006

The Black Magic & Indonesia’s Anti-Corruption Campaign

On July 4, 2001, Indonesia’s Attorney General Baharuddin Lopa died of a heart ailment in a hospital in Saudi Arabia. That was the formal statement from the State Palace. But the then-minister of defense, Mahfud MD, said that time, Lopa and his predecessor realized that their positions were vulnerable to possible poisoning or black-magic practices. This was a reference to Indonesians’ belief in the mystical powers, for good or evil, possessed by dukun (witch doctors). The evil witch doctors are called dukun santet.

Some newspapers that time hinted at black magic in their obituaries on Lopa. Who did that? Nobody knows.

The corruption charges against former president Soeharto were to be Lopa’s priorities. He believed in 1999 that he needs two of documents that the attorney general to drag Soeharto into court. Two weeks before his death, Lopa, as a crusading and incorruptible lawyer when he served as secretary general of the National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM), told a hearing with the House of Representatives that he would pursue several major cases concerning human-rights abuses in East Timor and several banking-corruption cases.

On Thursday, January 4, 2006, Special Prosecutor heading the Anti-Corruption Team Hendarman Supandji, claimed that he was the target of black magic campaign. He accused of those inflicted in the corruption case of Hilton Hotel’s use of state-owned land in Jakarta that cost the state of 1.7 trillion rupiah of loses.

“My bed was full of death maggots (belatung in Indonesian language),” Hendarman told the press after reporting the progress in anti-corruption efforts to President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

While he was claiming of no fear on such black magic campaign, Rakyat Merdeka reported on Friday that Hendarman was sick due to higher blood pressures. “I’m exhausted,” he said.

Attorney General Abdul Rahman Saleh responded the black magic campaign saying he was ready to challenge those witch doctors. “We’re not afraid of santet. We will move on with our drives to eradicate corruption,” he said yesterday.

In the Hilton Hotel case, president SBY had signed an approval to investigate the governor of South East Sulawesi Ali Mazi. Mazi hired by PT Indobuildco, the owner of Hilton Hotel, to process the land title for Hilton.

Two key figures of Golkar Party, the largest party in Indonesia’s parliament, Mr Pontjo Sutowo (president director of Indobuildco) and Mr Mahadi Sinambela (former minister for sports and youngster affairs), have been summoned in the case.

High-profile names like Ali Sadikin (former governor of Jakarta), Ali Rahman (former minister of state secretary during Abdurrahman Wahid administration) and Muladi (former minister of state secretary during BJ Habibie administration), have also been questioned over the case.

Hilton is one of cases being investigated by Hendarman’s team. While people generally praised the team’s drive on anti-graft campaign, critics said it is applying selective approach on the President’s enemies even though the team has been told to move against friends, colleagues, and family relations as well.

Former Assembly Speaker Amien Rais, for example, criticized the prosecution of small-time corruptors while big-fish are untouchables. PDI-P, the second largest party in the parliament, also felt that it is being targeted.

Analyst from Andalas University, Saldi Isra, wrote a column last month titled Tebang-Bilih Berantas Korupsi (literally means Selective Cutting in Corruption Eradication) saying there are too many cases shown of how the process of investigation and execution of verdicts have been discriminative.

He pointed the case of General Election Commission (KPU), Haj Funds, and 43 members of West Sumatra legislative council. Execution of Probosutedjo, a businessman and half-brother of former president Soeharto, only takes two days after the Supreme Court reject his appeal. It’s already six months after the Supreme Court rejected the appeal from 43 members of West Sumatra legislative council, but they are free still.

In the KPU case, the chairman Nazaruddin Syamsuddin had been convicted, some executive members had been prosecuted but other former members (Hamid Awaluddin, the current minister of justice and human rights and Anas Urbaningrum, the head of political department at Partai Demokrat, the party that promotes president SBY) are untouchables.

Attorney General immediately prosecute the KPU whistle-blower Khairiansyah of receiving US$1,000 from the Haj Funds, but did nothing on the long-list of receivers. It is good to show people the equality before the law in Khairiansyah’s prosecution, but it also confirmed of how easy to catch small-time thieves whilst leaving big-time corruptors enjoy their freedom. There are 12 fugitive corruptors embezzled trillion of rupiah each presently evading arrest.

The black magic issue clearly boosted the image of Attorney General’s Office so as to remind people of the same threats that cost Lopa’s life. But we do hope that the black magic issue was not designed to divert the issue of equality before the law, politically motivated prosecution, and impartiality in the execution of law.

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Wednesday, December 07, 2005

Lady Politician to lead Indonesia Moslem Intellectuals

Dr Marwah Daud Ibrahim, a South Sulawesi-born politician and former candidate for vice president (she was the running-mate of Abdurrahman Wahid, one of the presidential candidates last year), has been elected as chairwoman of a presidium that would lead the Indonesian Moslem Intellectuals Association (ICMI).
In a voting early morning on Wednesday Dr Marwah defeated Hatta Radjasa (minister of transportation), Dr Muslimin Nasution (incumbent chairman), and noted sociologist Prof. Azyumardi Azra.
What a sweet birthday gift. Marwah born in November 8, 1956. Marwah's last name is her husband’s (Ibrahim Tadju).
Dr Marwah is the first woman elected to lead the heavily male organization since its establishment 15 years ago. Mother of three, Marwah graduated from Hassanuddin University in 1981 majoring in communication. She earned master degree in communication from International American University, Washington (1982) and PhD with distinction from the same university in 1989.
It was BJ Habibie (that time as minister of research and technology) who awarded a scholarship for PhD program to Marwah. Back from US, she work closely with Habibie, that time also as the chairman of ICMI.
ICMI enjoys huge political grip during last terms of Soeharto’s 32 years in power when its founder Prof BJ Habibie become the vice president. The organization’s influence heighten during Habibie’s presidency, following the downfall of Soeharto in 1998. As for Dr Marwah, she was active at Golkar Party as one of executives. And as a close aide to Habibie, she serves the national board of the party and as a member of the House of Representatives (DPR).
But a humiliating defeat of Habibie in 1999 election cost the organization’s declining influence in the country’s politic and economy. But Wahid stunned everyboddy with his maneuver to name Marwah as his running-mate in last year’s election. They failed even before the first round was started.
But that’s not the end for Marwah. She was one of candidates to replace Golkar Party chairman Akbar Tanjung, but failed in the last round to Jusuf Kalla. Now, she won the presidency of ICMI.
The organization regained the momentum to revitalize its influence since Jusuf Kalla (member of ICMI) became vice president. And it is interesting to see how Dr Marwah revive its political muscle. Golkar and ICMI were so close during Soeharto and Habibie years. Could it be the same during Kalla’s years?

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Monday, December 05, 2005

Indonesia: New Cabinet Line-Up

Below is the new cabinet line-up announced Monday night in Yogyakarta by president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono and Vice President Jusuf Kalla. The decision was made after a limited cabinet meeting led by SBY and attended by VP Kalla with some ministers.

1) Coordinating minister for Economy: Dr Boediono (professional, former minister of finance). He is expected to bring back the macroeconomy stability to the country hurt by high inflation rate. Economist from Gajah Mada University Dr Sri Adiningsih optimistic Boediono would be able to deliver people's high hopes on him to revive the economy saying Indonesia's current situation is a lot better than in 2001 when Boediono was appointed minister of finance.

2) Coordinating minister for People's Welfare: Aburizal Bakrie (Golkar Party, led Bakrie Group, a diversified business).

3) Minister of Finance: Dr Sri Mulyani Indrawati (former minister of national development planning, professional)

4) Minister of National Development Planning/Chairman of Bappenas: Paskah Suzetta (chairman of the House Commission IX from Golkar Party). Paskah established two companies, PT Perisai Daya Usaha (property) and PT Perisai Daya Cipta (trading). He is a property businessman with various housing projects in West Java cities such as Bandung, Cibinong, and Padalarang. He is also president commissioner of Triniti Group (property business).

5) Minister of Industry: Fahmi Idris (former minister of manpower, Golkar Party). He is the owner of Kodel Group, one of biggest debtors to Indonesia Bank Restructuring Agency (IBRA). Born in Jakarta, on 20th September 1943, Fahmi failed to graduate from the University of Indonesia, majoring in economics. He was the deputy chairman of the Golkar Party. Fahmi was a student activist before becoming involved in politics. He started his political career as the chairman of the Golkar Party's Business and Economic Enterprise Department (1993-1998). He was manpower and transmigration minister in the Habibie administration. He was dismissed as the deputy chairman of Golkar during November 2004 for defying the party's order to support the reelection bid of President Megawati Soekarnoputri.

6) Minister of Manpower: Erman Suparno (Chairman of House Commission V from PKB). Erman is on old buddy of vice president Jusuf Kalla and deputy speaker of People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) Aksa Mahmud since 1970s when Erman was chief of South Sulawesi branch of PT Pembangunan Perumahan.Graduated from Newport University, California, Erman was president director of PT PP Tasei Indonesia Construction.


Ousted ministers:
1) Alwi Shihab (PKB, to be appointed as special envoy and advisor for president on Middle East, Islamic Conference Organization, and Islamic Development Bank)
2) Jusuf Anwar (Professional, to be appointed as ambassador, most likely to Japan)
3) Andung Nitimihardja (professional)

Labels: , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Round-up on cabinet reshuffle

Vice President Jusuf Kalla denied earlier reports today about the possibility to have two coordinating ministers in charge of economic affairs in a reshuffled cabinet to be announced tonight in Yogyakarta. Kalla will fly to the city at 5 PM to discuss the reshuffle with President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono. Kalla admitted he don't know the reshufle details.
President Soeharto once divided the economic portfolio into two coordinating ministers, one for finance/state budget/supervision and one for production/distribution. But that was a total mess that partly led to the financial crisis in 1997.
Detik.com claimed its source told that coordinating minister for welfare affairs Alwi Shihab would almost certain be ousted from the cabinet. The incument coordinating minister for economy Aburizal Bakrie will take Alwi's place as the incoming Dr Boediono will takeover Bakrie's post.
Bakrie seems to had raised the white flag with his statements that whoever replace him would not make difficult decisions anymore. "Difficult decision, raising the fuel price, has been taken. No more difficult decisions," he told regional representatives council (DPD) in a meeting this morning.
"I have no problem to be outside of this administration," Bakrie said.
Senior politican and DPR member Sarwono Kusumaatmadja (former minister under Soeharto, Habibie, and Wahid administrations) advised Bakrie that if he wants certainty, stay out of politics. "In politic, we have to deal with uncertainty. Whatever happens, let it go," Sarwono was quoted by Detik.com.
Tempointeraktif.com, meanwhile, reported that Alwi expressed that he is ready to be ousted and would accept an ambassador post as long as not for East Timor."That would be too cruel (to be Indonesian ambassador to East Timor)," Alwi said when asked about his next assignment.
House speaker Agung Laksono warned president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono that any move to oust Bakrie and Fami Idris (minister for manpower), both are Golkar Party cadres, would be dangerous.
Rumors this hours said economist Anggito Abimanyu, currently one of top officer at the ministry of finance and confidante of Dr Boediono when the later was the minister, might be promoted to chair the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas). Sri Mulyani Indrawati, the chairwoman of Bappenas, is tipped to replace Jusuf Anwar as minister of finance.

Labels: , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Second wind: Habibie & ICMI

Indonesian Moslem Intellectuals Association (ICMI) was one of the strongest political groups during the last years of Soeharto admnistration. His downfall in 1998 that followed by BJ Habibie's elevation to replace Soeharto only to be replaced in 1999 after a humiliating defeat in People's Consultative Assembly marked the downturn of ICMI's role in Indonesian politics.
After five years, with two presidents who were not friendly to ICMI, the organization slowly resume its influence when Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (SBY) and Jusuf Kalla won the presidency last year. Yesterday SBY officially opened ICMI's conference in Makassar, South Sulawesi, to select new leaders.
While ICMI never formally endorsed the pair, Vice President Kalla (member of ICMI executive) soon become its new patron. Kalla, born in Sulawesi like Habibie, managed to promote some ICMI executives to top jobs in the administration. Muhammad Said Didu, one of top executive at ICMI, has been appointed secretary of the powerful ministry for state-owned enterprises (MSOE). The current coordinating minister for economy Aburizal Bakrie is also member of expert council of ICMI.
Here we go. Some of cabinet members reportedly vying for ICMI's presidency. Transportation minister Hatta Radjasa and MSOE Sugiharto (ICMI treasurer) are among cabinet members tipped to replace Muslimin Nasution as ICMI chairman. Muslimin is former minister of forestry under Habibie administration. Muslimin and Jimmly Assidiqie (chairman of Constitutional Court) are strong candidates as well.
As for Habibie, who spent most of his time in Germany after 1999 defeat, he regularly attend formal and informal gatherings. Late last week, he even secured support from SBY administration to revive the ailing aircraft manufacturer PT Dirgantara Indonesia which went bankrupt due to huge debts made during Habibie's leadership at the company.
Yes, he cried for help to revive the company he found with huge support from Soeharto. SBY gave the answer late last week that Habibie may rebuild Dirgantara (formerly known as PT IPTN, dubbed by journalists as Industri Penerima Tamu Negara or Industry to Receive State Guests as during Soeharto years important guests were asked or directed to visit the aircraft manufacturer in Bandung, West Java).
Abdurrahman Wahid and Megawati Soekarnoputri administrations decided to streamline Dirgantara and cut heavily the staffs from 16,000 to 3,500. No details of Habibie's plan to return to Dirgantara. But any plan to revive Dirgantara with state budget might be rejected by the incoming new cabinet member Dr Boediono who is tipped as coordinating minister for economy or minister of finance.
But Dirgantara is one small thing on ICMI and Habibie. It is worth to read Zaim Uhrowi's (he is member of the ICMI revitalization team) article about revitalization of ICMI. He raised the question on ICMI's future, whether it should be close to the power holders or representing pure intellectuals face? The conference in Makassar deserved our attention, that's for sure.

Labels: , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, December 03, 2005

High hopes on Dr Boediono, doors closed for Dr Rizal Ramli

Dr Boediono (illustration courtesy of KCM), former minister of finance under Megawati Soekarnoputri admnistration and Minister/Chairman of National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) under BJ Habibie administration, is almost sure will be the coordinating minister for economy replacing Aburizal Bakrie. He would also lead Bappenas as its current leader Sri Mulyani Indrawati would replace Jusuf Anwar as the minister of finance.
People tend to react positively on Boediono's return to the economic team considering his good reputation and track record in the market. Who is he?
Dr Boediono born in Blitar, East Java, in February 25, 1943. He earned bachelor degree in economics from University of Western Australia (1967), master in economics from Monash University, Melbourne, Australia (1972), and PhD in business economics from Wharton School at University of Pennsylvania, USA (1979).
Married to Herati with two children and Spent most of his career with Bappenas, he was moved to Central Bank (Bank Indonesia) prior to crisis until his assignment as chairman of Bappenas. Cool and tight-lips, Boediono rarely make controversial statement.
He believes in three important factors to make Indonesia regain international confidence. First, good policies. Second, good will. Third, good luck. As he said over and over that the name of the game is confidence.
Market seems to welcome Boediono. But as he said, even though he could make good policies, Boediono needs good will and good luck to meet people's high expectation.
Economist Umar Juoro said Boediono's discipline in controlling state budget and inflation might be at odd with Vice President Jusuf Kalla who demands stimulus from state budget.
So far, no comments heard from Kalla despite claim made by The Jakarta Post that Kalla supports Boediono's entry to cabinet. The newspaper's claim based on a source close to SBY saying Boediono's appointment had been privately discussed between SBY and Kalla, who also chairs the Golkar Party, which controls the largest number of House seats.
The National Mandate Party (PAN) and the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), two strategic allies of SBY, have expressed support for Boediono's appointment. SBY's own party, Democrat Party, previously tipped Dr Rizal Ramli as coordinating minister for economy. But Boediono's appointment had almost close the door for Dr Ramli's entry to cabinet as both have different styles in economic policies. Dr Ramli was minister of finance and coordinating minister for economy under Abdurrahman Wahid's admnistration. He is a stauch critic of International Monetary Fund and World Bank.





Labels: , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Friday, December 02, 2005

Clearer picture of cabinet reshuffle

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono finally gave clearer signal of his plan to reshuffle the cabinet, especially the ecoomic ministers. SBY clearly stated that Dr Boediono, former minister of finance under Megawati Soekarnoputri administration and chairman of national development planning during BJ Habibie presidency, had accepted his offer even though Boediono prefers to enjoy his retirement as lecturer at Gajahmada University.
The president admitted that he had talked to Boediono yesterday and that he would be in the economic team. Would he be the chief economic minister replacing Aburizal Bakrie? No clear answer. "We need someone who understand macroeconomy," the president said, a stronger signal.
There is speculation that Boediono might return to his previous post as finance minister. "We will see each other at Lapangan Banteng (the ministry of finance office in Central Jakarta)," Boediono told Detik.com.
Rumors said energy minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro might be promoted to replace Aburizal while the later would replace Alwi Shihab as Coordinating Minister for People's Welfare Affairs. In this scenario, transportation minister Hatta Radjasa will replace Purnomo.
But should SBY needs Boediono to lead the economic team, most likely Dr Sri Mulyani Indrawati will be the finance minister replacing Jusuf Anwar.
Previous scenario was Aburizal would be moved to trade ministry and trade minister Mari Pangestu will replace Sri Mulyani's position as minister for national development planning.
Stock market reacts positively to Boediono news as he is seen capable to manage the economy. But everything could change until the last minute especially take into account a possible rebuff from Vice President Jusuf Kalla's camp. Kalla is the main supporter for Aburizal. (Kalla was reportedly rejected Boediono's candidacy as minister of finance when the cabinet was composed last year).
Other minister that most likely to be replaced is Andung Nitimihardja, the minister for industry and trade. Businessman Rahmat Gobel, a close aide to SBY and JK during last year's election, is tipped to replace Andung.

Labels: , , , ,


READ MORE!!!