Friday, January 19, 2007

Wiranto's scary observation

Antara quoted general (ret) Wiranto's various statements on Thursday. Among others, Wiranto worried about the country's security status. He described the current situation is somewhat similar with days before Soeharto's downfall in 1998 when he was military commander. Is it a political statement in his capacity as chairman of the newly established Hanura Party or based on his observation as someone familiar with conflicts ih the military structure?

Wiranto expressed his uneasy feeling about the situation he described as 'the straw under fire'. He worried about security outlook especially "if someone instigate the fire."
"For the time being, pray is the only medicine. Almost all predictions and analysis stated that something would happen, but nobody knows when. The situation is worrysome, that's why I appeal to those in power to fix it. We're in a very dangerous situation," Antara quoted Wiranto without details of who made the predictions and analysis nor intelligence report to support his statement.
Scary, isn't it?
But he dismissed speculation of military-supported coup d'etat. How about Revolution Committee established by former army chief of staff general (ret) Tyasno Sudarto? "It's not a physical revolution, it's a revolution of the heart," the former Golkar candidate for president in 2004 election. Despite his failure to pass the first round (third behind SBY & Megawati), no sign that Wiranto let his ambition dim to be Numero Uno. That's probably why he decided to exit from Golkar (the party most likely will support the chairman/VP Jusuf Kalla to contest in 2009) and established Hanura.
The State Palace is unbelieveably busy to respond the maneuver of retired generals as if no important issue need its utmost attention. I really don't get it. Five hundreds people went on a rally in front of The Palace's gates could forced the president to run the administration from his private residence? How about 61 million people who voted for him in 2004?
I'm sure millions out of the 61 voters were unemployed, expected SBY to deliver his promises to open up more jobs, higher economic growth (7% annually, not 5.2% average), but they may still unemployed. Worse, millions of the employee-voters are now unemployed. That would lead to social revolution, may be not during SBY's term in office thanks to the nation's remain strong social fabric system (though it's eroding due to modernism, urbanization, hedonism etc). So, Mr President, do something!

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, January 11, 2007

Wiranto joins anti-Exxon movement

General (ret) Wiranto, chairman of Hanura Party, has joined with an anti-ExxonMobil movement. He attended the seminar at parliament building hosted by the movement's leader Marwan Batubara who is close to Fuad Bawazier (former Soeharto's finance minister, now an executive at Wiranto's party).

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, December 19, 2006

Wiranto to declare new party

Gen (ret) Wiranto, who lost the 2004 president election, is scheduled to announce the establishment of new political party, tentatively called Partai Hati Nurani Rakyat (Hanura) with former high-ranking military officers, Jawa Pos reported.

Founding members of the new party are, among others: Fuad Bawazier (former finance minister under Soeharto regime), Subagyo HS (former army chief of staff), Fachroel Rozy (former deputy army commander), Suaedi Marasabesi, Elsa Syarief (lawyer for Tommy Soeharto), Bern K. Sondakh (former Navy chief of staff), etc.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Friday, November 24, 2006

President 2009 Hypothetical Election

My friend Tommy, a prominent political journalist, believes the presidential election in 2009 will be the race of four candidates: SBY, JK (Jusuf Kalla), AR (Amien Rais), and MS (Megawati). How about Wiranto & Sutiyoso who are establishing new political parties, inspired by SBY's Partai Demokrat in 2004?

"If a hypothetical election was held today, SBY would lost the battle. I don't think he has enough energy for 2009. He looks happy to have the chance to be the president and that's it. But if he runs, which I'm sure he will, SBY could still get enough votes to pass the first round," he concluded.
Wait a minute! Isn't SBY considered successful in eradicating corruption?
"On the surface, yes! But people at the grass root level won't buy that anymore. Besides, he must have created a lot more enemies in the last few years. They'll strike back at SBY. He also failed to impress Islamic groups. Look at his statement about Iraq," Tommy said.
But the the prosecution of some high-level officers have created psychological fears and it's good?
"So far, from PR point of view, it's partially true. But you can't be considered success when you stop at prosecutions and you only prosecute your foes or what popularly known as selective cutting."
How about SBY's Partai Demokrat?
"The party has been torn apart. At the central board, the split has been obvious. Even the party's founding member Sys NS proclaimed a new party. The party is bussy with local election projects," he added.
"It's quite clear now that JK will run for presidency. But he wouldn't pass the first round," Martin, another prominent journalist said.
"But JK is considered strong enough to grab most of the votes outside Java," I asked.
"Well, look at the result of direct gubernatorial elections outside Java. PDI-P won in North Sulawesi, Central Kalimantan, and two provinces in Papua. In that case, JK & Megawati could share outside Java," Abraham, a political observer answered.
Abraham also mentioned about two major win for PDI-P, North Sumatra & Lampung. In the later, PDI-P's Sjahroedin Pagaralam-Syamsurya Ryacudu (younger brother of former Army Chief of Staff Gen Ryamizard Ryacudu---Megawati's key ally) had just won almost three-year battle against Golkar's Thabrani.
"And if Megawati could get Akbar Tanjung as her running mate, they could easily take Sumatra. Tanjung is also acceptable for Moslem voters. Those who supported SBY in 2004 will easily move to support Akbar," Abraham added.
But why do you think that JK won't pass the first round?
"Because Golkar already splitted and Tanjung loyalists are working hard to block JK, especially because JK's recent statement that insulting Tanjung's camp. Look at Tanjung's statement on SBY's newly established team. He said it's the president's sole right to establish such team. The statement actually an attack to JK who opposed the team," Abraham said.
So, how do you explain Gamawan Fauzi's win in West Sumatra? Gamawan was promoted by PDI-P. Can we assume that Megawati could win West Sumatra while JK's wife is a native West Sumatra (from Tanah Datar regency) and SBY has been named Datuk with Irman Gusman (DPD member) as the promoter (in fact JK's son has also been named Datuk)?
"Well, West Sumatra is different game. Gamawan won not because of PDI-P, but his personality as clean figure. It's just a coincidence. If Amien run, he might still win there as shown in 2004," Abraham argued.
"But Tommy, don't you think that Amien Rais is already the past. He failed in the first round in 2004," I asked.
"Well, Amien is playing Evo Morales personality at the moment. I think he's quite smart to use the nationalism sentiment to attract 'nationalist' voters," Tommy argued.
"But do you think that voters would buy the radical nationalistic campaign?"
"I'm not saying Amien would win the election. But looking at his movement in the last few months, it's quite clear that he still has the ambition to run for 2009," Tommy said.
Martin, long-time observer of local politics, jump in the discussion. "We have to see the more interesting local elections in Banten and Jakarta. Then we could get better picture about voters in densely populated areas in Java," he said.
Who do you think will win in Banten?
"I think Atut from Golkar-PDI-P will win," Martin said.
And who do you thin will win Jakarta?
"I think if PDI-P endorse Agum Gumelar, he could win. But Fauzi Bowo is the strongest contender."
But how about PKS candidate Mr Adang Darajatun?
"He has money. But for God sake I don't understand why PKS endorse him? If PKS believes it has the largest supporters in the city, why don't promote Tifatul or Hidayat Nur Wahid?"
Well, you can't say Banten & Jakarta represent the whole Java because we have West Java, Central Java, and East Java with different voters character.
"I think SBY & Megawati could still get the bigger slice of voters in those most populous areas," Martin said.
Rahmon, an international politic analyst, entered the discussion. "You have to look at the possible turn around in US politics as well. You know from the history that US plays important role in Indonesia's leadership changes," he said.
So, in that case, US will lean to SBY?
"At the moment, yes. But if Democrat win the 2008 election, things will change accordingly," he said.
The discussion stopped because I had diarhea. We promised to continue the discussion next week!

Labels: , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Friday, September 22, 2006

Habibie's Memoir: Questions

Suppose that president Habibie didn't call miliary commander Wiranto to ask the general to stay in his position, would Wiranto tell Habibie about the 'existence' of Kostrad troops around State Palace and Habibie's residence? Why Wiranto didn't file a report before Habibie's call? Is there any convincing proofs about Prabowo's move? Why Habibie prefer to believe in Wiranto than Prabowo? Those are questions that remain unanswered in BJ Habibie's recently published book, Decisive Seconds.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Wednesday, September 20, 2006

Habibie's Decisive Seconds: Book Excerpts

Former president BJ Habibie's memoir, titled Decisive Seconds, tells us some interesting events about the transition of power from Soeharto, how he kick out general Prabowo---that time Kostrad Commander and still Soeharto's son-in-law, and how Soeharto rejected his appeals to meet, Kompas reported.

"This is an abasement. You fired me as Kostrad Commander?" Lt Gen Prabowo asked. "Not fired, replaced," Habibie replied.
"Why? I want to protect the President."
"That's the task of President's Security Forces with direct responsibility to Military Commander, not your job..."
"What kind of President are you? On behalf of my father's and my father-in-law's name, please give me three more months as Kostrad commander."
"No. Before the sun goes down, all Kostrad forces should be under the new commander."
That was the tense dialog between Prabowo & Habibie on May 22, 1998, less than 24 hours after Habibie sworn in as president.
The dialog was stopped when ret lt general Sintong Panjaitan cut the dialog and said...General, The President has no more time, leave the room...
Earlier that day, 06.10, Habibie called Gen Wiranto and asked him to stay in his position as TNI Commander. Wiranto reported to Habibie the movement of Kostrad forces around the State Palace and Habibie's residence at Patra Kuningan, South Jakarta.
At 07.30, commander general of Special Forces (Kopassus) Maj Gen Muchdi met Habibie with the letter from Gen (Ret) AH Nasution asking Habibie to promote Gen Subagyo HS as TNI Commander and Prabowo as Army's Chief of Staff (KSAD).

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, May 04, 2006

Morales Effect in Indonesia

Bolivia President Evo Morales stunned world's oil, gas, and mining establishments with his May Day decree. Under the decree, foreign companies in oil, gas, and mining must accept much tougher contract terms within six months or leave the country. Morales' nationalization does not entail a complete state takeover, as has occured in other countries. So far none of the big players, Petrobras, Repsol YPF, BG Group, or Total SA has pulled out. But as soon as they find the terms unprofitable, they will leave the country.
Morales Effect hit the neighboring countries, especially Brazil and Argentine, which rely their gas supply from Bolivia. As reported by The Wall Street Journal today, Morales decree drives metal prices even higher as he stated clearly that oil and gas nationalization is just the beginning and to be followed by other sectors including forestry.
Tanzania immediately follows Morales step with the announcement of the country's Chambers of Miners that government had set up a task force to review foreign mining contracts because the current terms benefit foreigners at the expense of locals.
The Latin American anti-establishment storm would even stronger if the nationalist presidential hopeful Ollanta Humala win the second-round runoff vote later this month. The controversial Venezuela president Hugo Chavez has threatened to nationalize mining industry as well.
Like his ideological soul mate and friend, President Hugo Chavez of Venezuela, Mr Morales is keen to diversify Bolivia's relations away from a dependence on the US. Historically, Bolivia's weak economy - the poorest in South America - has made it very vulnerable to US influence.
China, the energy hungry nation, is considered to play a role in developing Bolivia's oil and gas sector, as it is already doing in Venezuela.
How about Indonesia?
Actually the nationalist movement had mounted pressure to review the gold mining contract of PT Freeport Indonesia, the largest gold mining in the world, since late last year. President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono had asked minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro to review the contract. The nationalist is also targetting ExxonMobil's contract with Pertamina regarding the development of Cepu oil and gas project.
Some legislators then proposed to use the rights to investigate government over its decision to give ExxonMobil the operation right in Cepu Block. But when it comes to formal politics, only one party (PDI-P) which endorsed it. Legislator from PKS and PAN failed to convince its party leadership to support the move. Recently media also reported the breakup in PDI-P over the issue. So the movement in parliament has been weakened in the last few months.
But outside the parliament building, former Assembly Speaker Amien Rais keep the fight. He gathered support from senior politicians such as Try Sutrisno (former VP) and retired general Wiranto. This group failed to get spare time of president SBY to deliver their 'messages' and planned a major rally on May 20 instead.
But yesterday Amien trumpetted Morales Effect saying, "Our leader (President SBY) should act like Morales."
I'm sure he has good intention, to get better deal with big corporations like Freeport McMoRan and ExxonMobil which book unbelievable profit in the last few years. I support every efforts to renegotiate better terms for the people. What we need now is how to outsmart them.
It is true that Freeport, Exxon, or Caltex booked huge profit from their Indonesian operation. But we have to remember that local groups such as those who own PT Bumi Resources Tbk also recorded US$3.2 billion out of its divestment of coal mining companies. Look at how much money Bumi made last year? Rp1.2 trillion profit. That's also the case with Adaro Indonesia, Energi Mega Persada, or Medco Energi---all owned by local business groups.
We can't simply copy paste Morales decree because we have to analyze its full impact to the society. One's misery could be other's fortune. Kicking out the Spanish or UK companies, would open the door for China. The same could happen here. Kicking out US companies would be followed with huge fortune for some Indonesian business groups, but not necessarily means Indonesian people. We managed to kick out Rio Tinto and BP from Kaltim Prima Coal, but then we have Bumi Resources control it and got US$3.2 billion out of it. So, what we need is an overall arrangement of the level of playing field, not partial ones.
Great philosopher Jeremy Bentham said the best public policy is that which produces greatest happiness. We can't change a public policy that would bring miseries. It is our job, including the leaders of opposition movement, to find out the best policy. We're not in a rush anyway!

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, March 16, 2006

Amien Rais, Too Late the Hero

Former Assembly Speaker Amien Rais is the most active politician in the last few months, at least from public appearance.
Media love his 'harsh statements', such as...Freeport committed three major crimes...Don't be afraid of America, just close down Freeport operation...or illogical things such as...Freeport could resume operation as long as it could bring back the mountains...
I am 100% believe that Freeport committed wrongdoings, but I'm 100% sure our leaders (military and civilian) had contributed something in those problems. At the end of the tunnel, I believe also that someone would take benefits or losses out of this debacle.
Amien then jumped on the wagon of opposition towards government on Cepu settlement, in which both ExxonMobil and Pertamina agreed to have ExxonMobil as the operator of the block. He expressed his anger and uncrontrolled emotion with brand new accusation...I'm sorry to say that this administration has been involved in major corruption scandal...or...I don't know who the hell whispered them (government) to make this decision...
To make the case, Amien need friends. So he met former vice president Try Sutrisno Thursday night. DPD member Marwan Batubara, legislator Alvin Lie and Drajad Wibowo, and ICMI Chairwoman Marwah Daud Ibrahim were by his side. Amien said he can't sleep well since ExxonMobil won the operatorship.
But Amien was not lucky. Try's friends, former presidents Abdurrahman Wahid and Megawati Soekarnoputri, and former House Speaker Akbar Tanjung were not there. Wahid, Try, Megawati, Wiranto, and Akbar get together quite often in the last few months, but Amien was not member of the group. So, they must thought like this...why Amien need us now while he never show up whenever we sit down and criticize government on various issues in the past? Or, OK, so he need us when he has agenda?
I have to say, Amien is too late the hero in Cepu debacle. He was the Assembly Speaker when Pertamina approved the acquisition of Humpuss remaining shares in Cepu block back in June 2001. That was the critical moment of truth for the Exxon to get 100% control over Cepu block. Where was Amien then?
Another critical moment is when government-sanctioned negotiations team signed the memorandum of understanding with ExxonMobil in June 2005. Based on the MoU, government then awarded the cooperation contract (KKS) in September 2005 in which government agreed upon 85% revenue split from Cepu, and 15% for contractors. Government also agreed that the contractor shareholding at 45% for Pertamina, 45% for ExxonMobil, and 10% for local administrations.
Did you ever read Amien's opposition to this agreement? Operatorship agreement, signed yesterday, actually the derivative of the KKS, technical issue that less significant than the KKS. Amien justify his accusations based on the JOA.
Well, Amien apparently is too late to learn the facts and just too fast to judge, accuse, and talk. Amien should do his homework, to learn more to be a wise man. Otherwise, he is just a horse for those who are smart enough to ride on him.

Labels: , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, December 15, 2005

Rejects the verdict, president legitimacy is in question?

“Election should be repeated as the consequence of the verdict,” the University of Indonesia professor said arguing the decision to legalize the questioned ballot papers was taken without a plenary meeting.

Nazaruddin stands trial on corruption charges arising out of an insurance scheme for all KPU officials. He is accused of directly appointing PT Asuransi Bumida, instead of putting out the project to competitive tender. He also allegedly received US$45,000 in kickbacks from the insurance company.

He rejects the verdict and would appeal to higher court. “I legalized the invalid ballot papers without plenary meeting because of time constraint. The same applied to the appointment of the insurance company. If judges decided the direct appointment as a wrongdoing, it means the decision to legalize invalid ballot papers would be wrong as well. In that case, we have to repeat the presidential election,” he said.

During the election, there was continuing confusion about KPU’s decision to count ballot papers with two holes punched through them. This happened because voters failed to unfold them completely before using a nail to make a hole through the name of their preferred candidate.

That time KPU didn’t say how many votes had initially been declared valid and then needed to be included in the count. But such invalid punch-through was happened in the first round with five candidates. Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono and Megawati Soekarnoputri secured the top two to contest in the second round. I never heard of such invalid ballot papers in the second round with SBY as the clear winner.

Would the election give completely different result if Megawati failed to pass the first round and SBY have to fight with his former boss general (retired) Wiranto (ranked third in the first round)?

I am not a legal expert. But I do believe Nazaruddin’s decision on invalid ballot papers and insurance coverage should be treated separately. Personally, I missed the second round of election last year, but I believe we’re just too tired to have another election this year or next year.

As for Nazaruddin, even though he might not received kickbacks from the insurance company, such a direct appointment without an open bidding, is an act against the law of fair business competition. In that case, he might have a normal life and give lectures in political science and only pay fines under the competition law.

Born in Bireun, Aceh in November 5, 1944, Nazaruddin graduated from University of Indonesia in 1970. He got master degree and PhD from Australian Monash University.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, November 05, 2005

Aburizal Bakrie: No more waltz?

Aburizal Bakrie, coordinating minister for economic affairs, would turn 59, next week. Want to give birthday gift?

I am sure he is expecting great gift from president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono i.e. maintain his position as chief economic minister. Or at least lower prestigious post like minister of trade affairs should the president reshuffle the cabinet as been promised.

He is blamed for poor economic condition, growing business nepotism, and people’s miseries over the fuel price hike. His is the main target of a cabinet reshuffle. But with his strong financial and political backup, it is not easy for the president to simply kick him out of the cabinet.

Vice President Jusuf Kalla, who also the chairman of Golkary Party, is his main supporter. But in the last few months he managed to have other leading political figures behind him. National Mandate Party (PAN) chairman Sutrisno Bachir is one of them.

A simple knock out would be dangerous for the president himself as it could intensify competition with Kalla. But keep him in the post could cost the president’s popular support. A modest solution would be likely i.e. moving Aburizal to other cabinet post. Sources at the State Palace said Aburizal might be appointed trade affairs minister, still a high-profile ministry dealing with international trade issues, one of his favorites.

Who is Aburizal anyway?

Aburizal was born in Jakarta November 15, 1946 from the late businessman Achmad Bakrie who established PT Bakrie & Brothers Tbk, one of the largest conglomerates during Soeharto’s 32-year in power. The family lost control over the listed diversified group after a debt restructuring in early 2000. But it regained the control recently and resumed its expansive style in the last few months.

Husband of Taty Murniatriaty and father of three (Anindya Noverdian, Anindhita Anestia, and Anindra Ardiansyah), Ical (popularly called) was one of five contenders in Golkar Party’s selection of presidential candidate last year. Despite his strong financial support, Ical lost the race to retired general Wiranto.

Ical led Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry for almost a decade. He was graduated from Bandung Institute of Technology in 1973 majoring electronic and electricity technology.

As the oldest, he led the Bakrie family business with siblings Roosmania Helanbudi Kusmulyono (husband of BS Kusmulyono, commissioner at state-owned PT Bank Rakyat Indonesia Tbk, appointed few months ago), Nirwan Bakrie, and Indra Usmansyah Bakrie.

As reported to Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) last year, Ical has personal wealth of Rp1.19 trillion (almost US$200 million) and debt of US$35 million. He is the wealthiest person in the cabinet.

Thanks to his good habit of three hours of sport every day, Ical looks younger than his age. He hates smoking and easily angry whenever spotted his smoking staffs. He loves singing romantic songs the most. He likes little bit waltz and cha-cha, but not a regular dancer. “I only dance whenever someone asking me for a company,” he said.

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Wednesday, August 31, 2005

Rizal Ramli is tipped to lead new economic team


Rumors said Dr Rizal Ramli, former chief economic minister under Abdurrahman Wahid administration, is tipped to replace Aburizal Bakrie, while Dr Boediono, former finance minister under Megawati Soekarnoputri presidency will resume his position to replace Jusuf Anwar.
“Mr Ramli has intense communication with President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, but it is not clear whether it has something to do with a possible appointment as chief economic minister,” said one economist close to Ramli this morning.
The problem with Ramli is strong resistance from Vice President Jusuf Kalla who want to keep Aburizal in his post. “Aburizal himself will fight hard to keep the job,” he said.
Meanwhile, Dr Boediono, a credible figure in the market, also seen as the best candidate to replace Aburizal or Jusuf Anwar. “But it’s almost impossible for Boediono and Ramli in a team. President has to choose,” said other economist.
Who is Ramli?
Dr. Ramli was born in Padang, West Sumatra, May 10, 1953. He was imprisoned in the 1970s as a student activist and staunch critic of former President Soeharto. He majored in Physics at the Bandung Institute of Technology, completed graduate coursework at Sophia University Tokyo and earned his M.A (1982) and Ph.D in Economics (1990) at Boston University.
Prior to his government posting, Dr. Ramli headed the ECONIT (Advisory Group in Economics, Industry and Trade) think tank and consultancy. Shortly before President Soeharto's downfall, he led a protest with human rights groups against the World Bank, saying the Bank was aware of widespread corruption in Indonesia and closed its eyes to it. Appointed by Gus Dur as Chairman of the National Logistics Agency (Bulog) in April, 2000, Dr. Ramli was named Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs August 23, 2000. Ramli was at odd with International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank due to his policies and public comments.
He was appointed finance minister at the end of Gus Dur’s administration but out of cabinet since Megawati Soekarnoputri appointed President in 2002. He then criticized Megawati’s economic team as fake reformists and claimed himself as the true reformist.
Presidential candidate general (retired) Wiranto appointed Dr Ramli as economic advisor with promise to restore his old job. Wiranto failed in the first phase of the election and Dr Ramli then moved to Yudhoyono’s camp and tipped as one of candidates to be economic minister.
Dr Ramli was there when Yudhoyono defended his dissertation to earn PhD from Bogor Institute of Agriculture in early October 2004. “He has strong vision on people. I was amazed with quantitative method in his dissertation,” lauded Dr Ramli on Dr Yudhoyono.
As mentioned by noted economist Dr Sadli, Yudhoyono favored Dr Ramli as chief economic minister but Kalla insisted to have Aburizal. Kalla won, and Dr Ramli completely out of the cabinet.
In early November 2004, President Yudhoyono summoned Dr Ramli to State Palace for undisclosed agenda. Rumors that time said he will chair National Economic Council that gives economic advise to president. He denied the rumor, no such council established and Yudhoyono appointed Dr Sjahrir (Harvard alumni) as advisor instead. Dr Sjahrir has close relationship with Aburizal.
Last week, Dr Ramli made a strong statement that chaos over unrealistic 2006 State Budget is mainly due to wrong input given to President. Could Dr Ramli, or Dr Yudhoyono to be precise, win the race this time against VP Kalla and Aburizal?

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!