I'm so glad to read an article written by Orin Basuki, reporter of
Kompas, the largest newspaper in Indonesia, under the title...chasing the truth to San Ramon. The article is basically based on an audit report completed by Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) on PT Chevron Pacific Indonesia, a subsidiary of Chevron Corp, USA.
The article is centered on cost recovery, a term in oil and gas business in which contractors such as Chevron claim the costs to government/state.
BPK found the following irregularities at Chevron:
1) Caltex polytechnic Riau: Cost recovery claimed US$6.56 million. (So the education & training facility is not a donation of Chevron, it's a state-funded institution)
2) School cost: Cost recovery claimed US$6.29 million for 2004 & 2005. (Again, this is no corporate social responsibility/CSR, it's a state-sponsored)
3) Donation to international school: Cost recovery claimed US$5.94 million. (This isn't a CSR for God sake)
4) Community development & community relationship: Cost recovery claimed US$1.5 million and US$1.47 million respectively. (Not CSR, state-funded activity)
5) Interest recovery: US$4.97 million (this should not be charged as cost recovery item)
6) Modification of collecting stations US$33.98 million: No benefits for the operation.
7) Materials worth US$18.92 million, no gain, charged as cost recovery.
8) Electricity and steam supplied by PT Mandau Cipta Tenaga Nusantara have been doubted the fairness and would cost the government US$210 million and loss to the state at US$1.23 billion.
BPK auditors admit there should be a long list of items that deserved cost recovery, but government's position in most contracts is so weak that contractors tend to mark up cost recovery and charge everything in the mechanism. "Even they charged the cost to pay foreign teachers for expatriate's children or scholarship for children of local staffs. In the end, cost recovery is about the same with all the company's operational costs," Arief Handoko, BPK auditor told Kompas.
Worse, as explained by J Widodo Mumpuni, chief auditor on Chevron, government's position in the contracts is so weak that it coudn't blame contractors for the markups even though they put the country at huge financial losses.
This is what I mentioned in my previous article Chevron in Indonesia: A Wakeup Call.
I hope Kompas would continue the publication of other audit results over oil contractors such as ExxonMobil, ConocoPhillips, Petrochina, CNOOC, Medco Energi, Energi Mega Persada, Pacific Oil & Gas, Santos, Star Energy, Pertamina, Petronas, etc.
Not just that we're aware of how these contractors made lots of money from the country's resources, but we know how careless our government officers (including BP Migas) in performing their role as regulator and supervisor. With that, we know what we should fix right now.Labels: BP Migas, CHEVRON, Electricity, Energi Mega Persada, ExxonMobil, Medco, Oil Gas, Pertamina, Star Energy
READ MORE!!!
