Tuesday, October 31, 2006

BP Migas chairmanship price tag: Rp15 billion

I got information from a friend legislator that candidates for Upstream Oil & Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas) chairman could win the upcoming selection (to replace Kardaya Warnika) with at least Rp15 billion investment (read as bribery) to buy the votes.

"You don't have to have Rp15 billion in hands. We could help you to get sponsorship with certain concessions," he said. The House of Representative (DPR) will conduct fit and proper test to select the new BP Migas chairman, one of the most powerful position in the country's oil & gas business.
I wonder whether Kardaya spent that much when he competes with Iin Arifin Takhyan (currently vice president director of Pertamina) and Triyana Kartoatmodjo (currently deputy chairman of BP Migas) for the post early last year.
Iin was initially the strongest candidate endorsed by government, but Kardaya won majority support from DPR, Tempointeraktif.com reported last year.

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, October 26, 2006

Chevron in Indonesia: A Wakeup Call (2)

I'm so glad to read an article written by Orin Basuki, reporter of Kompas, the largest newspaper in Indonesia, under the title...chasing the truth to San Ramon. The article is basically based on an audit report completed by Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) on PT Chevron Pacific Indonesia, a subsidiary of Chevron Corp, USA.

The article is centered on cost recovery, a term in oil and gas business in which contractors such as Chevron claim the costs to government/state.
BPK found the following irregularities at Chevron:
1) Caltex polytechnic Riau: Cost recovery claimed US$6.56 million. (So the education & training facility is not a donation of Chevron, it's a state-funded institution)
2) School cost: Cost recovery claimed US$6.29 million for 2004 & 2005. (Again, this is no corporate social responsibility/CSR, it's a state-sponsored)
3) Donation to international school: Cost recovery claimed US$5.94 million. (This isn't a CSR for God sake)
4) Community development & community relationship: Cost recovery claimed US$1.5 million and US$1.47 million respectively. (Not CSR, state-funded activity)
5) Interest recovery: US$4.97 million (this should not be charged as cost recovery item)
6) Modification of collecting stations US$33.98 million: No benefits for the operation.
7) Materials worth US$18.92 million, no gain, charged as cost recovery.
8) Electricity and steam supplied by PT Mandau Cipta Tenaga Nusantara have been doubted the fairness and would cost the government US$210 million and loss to the state at US$1.23 billion.
BPK auditors admit there should be a long list of items that deserved cost recovery, but government's position in most contracts is so weak that contractors tend to mark up cost recovery and charge everything in the mechanism. "Even they charged the cost to pay foreign teachers for expatriate's children or scholarship for children of local staffs. In the end, cost recovery is about the same with all the company's operational costs," Arief Handoko, BPK auditor told Kompas.
Worse, as explained by J Widodo Mumpuni, chief auditor on Chevron, government's position in the contracts is so weak that it coudn't blame contractors for the markups even though they put the country at huge financial losses.
This is what I mentioned in my previous article Chevron in Indonesia: A Wakeup Call.
I hope Kompas would continue the publication of other audit results over oil contractors such as ExxonMobil, ConocoPhillips, Petrochina, CNOOC, Medco Energi, Energi Mega Persada, Pacific Oil & Gas, Santos, Star Energy, Pertamina, Petronas, etc.
Not just that we're aware of how these contractors made lots of money from the country's resources, but we know how careless our government officers (including BP Migas) in performing their role as regulator and supervisor. With that, we know what we should fix right now.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, August 19, 2006

BP Migas: Anadarko failed to find oil

Upstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas) said UK-based Anadarko Indonesia Company failed to find oil reserves at two exploration drillings of North East Madura III block it acquired from Chevron (40%) in June, Bisnis Indonesia reported.

Doddy Hidayat, deputy operational at BP Migas, confirmed the failure but gave no details. "That's the fact," he said.
In June, Chevron and Anadarko entered into a swap agreement in which Chevron divest all its interests in five blocks (Bukat, Ambalat, Muara Bakau, Popodi, and Papalang)---all in East Kalimantan---to Anadarko in exchange of 40% working interest in North East Madura III block.
Chevron had 33.75% shares in Bukat and Ambalat, 50% at Muara Bakau, and 24% at Popodi and Papalang respectively.

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, July 27, 2006

Conflicting statements over Lapindo disaster

The newly appointed director general for oil and gas at the ministry of energy Mr Luluk Sumiarso said yesterday that Lapindo Brantas Inc could claim the cost incurred from hot mudflow disaster in its Banjar Panji-1 drilling to government. His statement is completely the opposite of Upstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas) chairman Kardaya Warnika who rejected such claim. So, who's right?

Both officers quoted the contract as the rationale behind their statements. I would say it's just way too premature to make such statements as it's not clear yet whether there were miss of conducts during the drilling that caused the disaster.
Luluk also defended Lapindo saying its partners (Medco and Santos) should be held responsible for the disaster as well while Medco rejected to take that arguing Lapindo is the operator. On this issue, would be better if Lapindo, Medco & Santos disclosed their agreements on operatorship.

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Wednesday, July 19, 2006

Indonesia Gas War Part II

The decision of Downstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BPH Migas) to appoint Bakrie Brothers as the operator of 1,200 km long gas pipeline linking East Kalimantan and Java has sparked Gas War II in the country.


Upstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas) Chairman Kardaya Warnika responded immediately the decision with his same-old statement that the gas reserves in East Kalimantan will not enough to support the pipeline.
We have two alliances at odds. First, BP Migas with gas producers in East Kalimantan such as Chevron (previously Unocal), Total Fina, and Arco/BP, PT LNG Badak (a joint venture of some companies) plus POG which plans to build new LNG plant in Bontang, and LNG customers in Japan, South Korea, & Taiwan (plus may be later on China). On top of this, several major gas customers in East Kalimantan such as PT Pupuk Kaltim (ammonia and urea producer), PT Kaltim Methanol Industry (methanol), PT Kaltim Pasifik Amoniak (ammonia), and PT Kaltim Parna Industry (ammonia).
Second, BPH Migas with domestic customers in Java and local pipe manufacturers which will take benefit out of the pipeline project.
The first group might say, sorry we have no more gas for you (Bakrie pipeline) because we have long-term contracts in hands at US$9/MMBTU. We could consider not to renew the contracts when they matured, but you have to pay the same export price. No way we will sell at US$3/MMBTU. Transporting gas to Java may help gas supply for power plants and manufacturing industries in Java, but at US$3/MMBTU, the country lost the foreign exhange earning of US$6/MMBTU. Without gas supply, no way that Bakrie could build the pipeline. Japanese LNG buyers are reportedly furious about the pipeline plan.
The second group, on the other end, 'may' push government to implement what we understand as Domestic Gas Obligation (DMO) wherein gas producers have the obligation to sell their output to domestic market first. But at what price, that's the question. This group argues gas pipeline would create more multiplier effects than exporting LNG.
What are the multiplier effects? Boost the pipe manufacturing industry, for sure, including Bakrie's pipe business. Power generation may be next in line because out of 10,000 MW new power plants to be built in the next five years, most will be coal-fired, not gas-fired. So this argument might be considered weak. Besides, if the country really want to develop multiplier effect of natural gas, why not build more gas-based chemical plants in East Kalimantan along with the power plants?
East Kalimantan already the largest ammonia producer in the world with more than 4 million tones per year capacity (through Pupuk Kaltim, KPA & KPI); the largest methanol (through KMI & Methanol Bunyu) with 1 million tones/year; and the largest urea producer in one site (3 million tones/year). We could build more of such plants, not to mention the mid-stream chemicals like acrylonitrile, caprolactam, nitric acid or ammonium nitrate (raw material for explossives, increasingly important with the growing mining industry in Indonesia/the world), all of which uses natural gas as feedstock.
The strategy to build more manufacturing facilities outside Java would deconcentrate both people and energy consumption in Java, right? And it's politically correct in the decentralization strategy.
The war is on and the winner might be decided by politics & power play instead of economic reasons.

Labels: , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, July 18, 2006

Lapindo disaster updates

Upstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas) insisted that Lapindo Brantas Inc, a unit of listed company PT Energi Mega Persada Tbk, can't claim cost recovery for losses due its drilling failure which caused hot mudflow disaster in Porong district, East Java.

BP Migas chairman Kardaya Warnika said according to article 5 point 4.2. of the contractor agreement, the losses prior to production is the contractor's full responsibility.
"Disaster during planning and implementation of drilling is the responsibility of contractor, so there will not be cost recovery," he said.
The statement dismissed earlier claim made by Energi Mega that part of the losses would be claimed as cost recovery that will be deducted from government's revenue from the block.
In the field, Lapindo and BP Migas failed to stop the hot mudflow with snubbing unit. It's not clear for how long people should suffer for the air and water pollution.
RELATED ARTICLES
1) Hot mudflow to be offloaded to the sea
2) Lapindo Case: The scapegoats

3) Lapindo mudflow: The family affair

4) Lapindo mudflow & blame games

5) 6 Suspects in Lapindo case

6) Gov't would bear the cost, how generous
7)Lapindo disaster spillover to Bumi-Energy merger

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Thursday, June 29, 2006

Kardaya Warnika on the hot seat

"He is just like 'God' for oil and gas executives in Indonesia," a friend said. But the most powerful man in the country's oil and gas business is obviously on the hot seat especially since Lapindo Brantas Inc failed to stop the flow of hot mud from its Banjar Panji-1 well that forced thousands of innocent people in Sidoarjo, East Java live in tents for weeks already and no sign of an immediate settlement.

Kardaya's men, Lapindo executives, and workers from Lapindo's subcontractors have been quized by East Java police as witnesses in the case. No one has been named suspect in the fiasco. Appart of police investigation, public pressures mounts on government (especially energy ministry) which easily pointed its fingers to BP Migas, the upstream oil and gas regulatory body.
As the chairman of BP Migas, Kardaya has been under public pressure to be held accountable for the disaster. Mr Kardaya was appointed chairman of BP Migas early last year.
Dr. Kardaya Warnika was born in Cirebon, in 1952. He completed his first degree in petroleum engineering from Bandung Institute of Technology (ITB) in 1978. He worked for state-owned oil and gas company Pertamina from 1978 to 1982. Kardaya received his PhD from Ecole Natur Superior du Petrol de Motors (ENSPM), IFP France in 1987.
He was Assistant to Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources on Economics and Financial Affairs in 2001-2003 and as deputy to the chairman of BP Migas during 2003-2005.He is a confidante of Purnomo Yusgiantoro, energy minister.

Labels: , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, June 27, 2006

Lapindo case: The Scapegoats!

East Java police have summoned three workers from PT Medici Citra Nusa, a sub-contracting company for Lapindo Brantas Inc's Banjar Pandji-1 drilling in an investigation of ongoing hazardous mudflow in Sidoardjo.

In contrast to the report of PT Energi Mega Persada (EMP) Tbk---parent company of Lapindo---to Jakarta Stock Exchange (JSX) and shareholders late last week that the drilling activities had been in line with standard operating procedure, the workers at Medici, as the witness in the case (no suspect named yet), admitted there was an error in drilling procedure at Banjar Panji-1 precisely as what has been circulated among engineers.
According to the SOP, casing should be installed when the drilling reach 8,500 feet. But even when the drilling had reached 8,750 feet, no casing installed. Unfortunately, the police didn't disclose further on the next question, why no casing? Was it intentional? Was it pure technical ignorance or managerial ones?
Hopefully things would be clearer when police concluded the investigation on Lapindo president director Imam P. Agustino and officers from BP Migas (Upstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body) and Energy Ministry. Otherwise we could only have scapegoats as suspects in the disaster that had forced more than 5,000 people to vacant their homes. Because we have a strong scapegoating psychology here!

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, June 24, 2006

Gov't would bear the cost of Lapindo disaster, how generous!

As the number of people forced to leave their homes has reached 5,000 following the mudflow from Lapindo Brantas drilling activities in Sidoarjo, PT Energi Mega Persada (EMP)---Lapindo's parent company claimed that the loses inflicted will be setoff with government's profit sharing from the operation. How generous!


In a letter dated June 22 to Jakarta Stock Exchange, EMP management stated as follows:
First, the company has implemented all standard operating procedures for well control in such drilling activities.
Second, Lapindo has insured the well drilling activities and the cost related to the evacuation of the community so the losses and damages inflicted will be covered by the Insurance Company. In addition, the losses and damages inflicted will also be setoff in the distribution of profits with the government.
Unfortunately, the company didn't elaborate further the second statement. What they really meant with setoff in the distribution of profits with the government.
By law, Lapindo or EMP is just a contractor for the state under a profit sharing mechanism. Normally for oil, the contractor would get 30%, while government 70% and for gas the portion could be 15% and 85% after all the costs deducted. So, there is a possibility that Lapindo will record the losses and damages inflicted as cost component to be recovered by government that would result in a lower profit sharing for the state.
I just can't get it. The company had been secured with insurance coverage for the losses and damages inflicted, but still has to claim the losses to the state?
I was happy when Vice President Jusuf Kalla stated early this week that Lapindo's controlling shareholder (Bakrie Family) should bear all the costs inflicted, including compensations that should be paid to all the victims. Both BP Migas, Energy Minister, and VP Jusuf Kalla have to clarify, once again, that the state would not bear the losses and damages inflicted.
And on EMP's self-proclaimed SOP that has been fully implemented in the drilling, I have to say that's a way too early conclusion and very much in contrast with earlier statements made by Energy Minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro that the disaster is a pure drilling failure. So, if Lapindo had implemented all the SOPs, why the mudflow at the rate of 25 thousands cubic meter keeps on and ruin many companies activities in the region?

Labels: , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, June 13, 2006

Lapindo Brantas spillover Energy-Bumi merger

Minister for environmental affairs Rachmat Witoelar threathened to terminate the operation of Lapindo Brantas in East Java for its failure to apply prudent operating measures that led to massive pollution from an East Java gas well.

Blame games at play, as usual. Lapindo's shareholder PT Medco E & P Brantas, a unit of the listed PT Medco Energi Internasional Tbk, said in a letter to Lapindo that it had reminded the firm on May 18 to set casing at a depth of 8,500 feet, as agreed in the drilling program, The Jakarta Post wrote today.
Lapindo Brantas Inc is a subsidiary of listed PT Energi Mega Persada Tbk (closely linked to Bakrie Family). This company is the designated operator of the Brantas PSC and it owns a 50% participating interest. Other shareholders at Brantas PSC are Medco (32%) and Australian Santos (18%).
Having purchased its participating interest in the mid-1990's, EMP built the Brantas PSC to be the single largest supplier of gas to the East Java PGN distribution network by 2004 from the Wunut Field.
According to Energi's annual report 2005, last year Brantas PSC produced average of 51 MMSCFD of natural gas and 14 barrel oil per day, almost half of Energi's total gas production.
Brantas PSC has up to 7 oil and gas prospects with contingent resources of up to 66 bcf under a contract mature in 2020. With prospective oil reserves of 244 million barrel and 1.35 BCF of natural gas, Brantas PSC is one of EMP's important source of income.
Oil production from the discovery in Tanggulangin field at Brantas PSC is expected to reach over 3,000 bopd by 2007.
With such significance, the question is whether Witoelar is serious enough to close down Lapindo Brantas operation. But as quoted by The Jakarta Post, Witoelar said his ministry has no authority to order Lapindo to halt its operations, asides from giving a recommendation to do so to the Energy and Mineral Resources Ministry and the Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas) which issued the exploration license.
Closing down the company's operation may create another problem, gas scarcity for electricity generating company PLN. Punishments should be strong enough to push this company implement stringent measures in its future operation.
Whatever the government decision might be, the catastrophe potentially will influence the planned merger of Energi with PT Bumi Resources Tbk. The rehabilitation might take few months and not to mention potential litigation toward the company.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Wednesday, April 26, 2006

Medco confirmed Block A acquisition from Exxon

Listed energy company PT Medco Energi Internasional Tbk. (MedcoEnergi) confirmed my earlier report that it won the bidding to acquire ExxonMobil's 50% interest in Block A oil and gas in Aceh.
According to its letter to Jakarta Stock Exchange (JSX) today, Medco Energi through its wholly owned subsidiary, Medco Far East Limited, and its partners, Japan Petroleum Exploration Co, Ltd. (Japex), and Premier Oil Plc. (Premier), have signed a Share Sale Agreement (SSA) with ExxonMobil Block A Investment Limited (ExxonMobil) to purchase 100% shares of Mobil Block A Limited (MBAL), a wholly owned subsidiary of ExxonMobil. MBAL holds 50% of interests in Block A Production Sharing Contract (Block A PSC) located in Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam province.
Upon the completion, MedcoEnergi, Japex, and Premier will each hold 33-1/3% of shares in MBAL, respectively. The remaining 50% interests in the Block A PSC are held by ConocoPhillips Company.
MedcoEnergi and its partners will change the name of MBAL immediately and report the changes to The Indonesian Oil and Gas Implementing Body (BP MIGAS).
The Block A PSC is located in the province of Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam in northern tip of Sumatra island, approximately 45 kilometres west of the giant ExxonMobil-operated Arun gas field. The PSC term period is 30 years which will expire in August, 31, 2011.

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!

Wednesday, March 29, 2006

Indonesia government to implement e-biding

In a move to minimize corruption, president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono signed a decree to implement e-biding system so all government transactions are transparent enough to any citizen interested in the procurement of services and goods.
National Development Planning Minister Paskah Suzetta said government will establish a website dedicated to government agencies, independent commissions, state-owned enterprises, local administrations, and companies owned by local or regional administrations. Under the decree, these organizations should announce all plans to procure goods and services in the website.
Indonesia government is ranked as the most corruptive nation in the world partly because of poor transparency in its procurement of goods and services. But e-biding should be more than just announcements.
In fact, in the last few years, some government-related agencies and state-owned companies have started to implement e-procurement system. Take for example Pertamina. But if you enter the website www.pertamina.com, you'll only find tender announcement in Indonesia language. That's not fair indeed.
The Upstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas) at www.bpmigas.com is better, even though not all the tender announcement available in both Indonesian and English.
E-bidding or E-procurement should be designed as a user-friendly system that just needs a controlled password from users and buyers to get into the system. The system should also has full electronic audit trail archive that allows one to able to view every bid that has been submitted, by whom and when upon completion of the bid. The inclusion of the bidding history paves the way for a bidding process that is fair and ethical.
I believe, full e-procurement is not yet possible because electronic documents are yet to be given legal status in the Indonesian courts. Thus all key documents must still be handled in the conventional manner. So to make the e-bidding, e-tendering or e-procurement as an important system in combating corruption needs serious drafting of e-commerce bill. But as the first step, the new website would improve transparency. Good move.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Sunday, March 19, 2006

Anadarco to invest US$50 million in six oil wells in Indonesia

A United States-based oil and gas company, Anadarco, will undertake explorations in six oil wells in Northeast Madura III Block with an investment of US$50 million, an official said here Friday, Antara reported.

The explorations in the Northeast Madura III Block, which is situated north of Madura island or 88 km from Sumenep district, will be the first for the American oil firm, BP Migas chief spokesman Amir Hamzah said after a discussion with East Java governor Imam Utomo on the proposed oil exploration.

Anadarco has invested totally US$25 trillion around the world, Amir said adding that the US oil and gas firm has mostly made investment in Algeria.

It is hoped that Anadarco will start producing oil in 2009-2010 if it success in exploring the oil wells, he said adding that the American oil and gas firm will share the oil fields with publicly-listed Medco Energy International if Anadarco successfully explores the oil wells.

Amir, however, did not mention the amount of the oil deposit in the Northeast Madura III Block but said the oil reserve was enormous.

The discovering of the six new oil wells in the Northeast Madura Block was made after a production sharing contractor namely Australia`s Santos Limited found an oil field in Jeruk waters in East Java Basin.

Anadarco signed a work contract with the Executive Body of Oil and Gas Upstream Activity (BP Migas) to explore oil in Indonesia late 2004.

Labels: ,


READ MORE!!!

Tuesday, March 07, 2006

Natuna D-Alpha: Another headache for ExxonMobil

ExxonMobil Oil Indonesia Inc, a subsidiary of US giant ExxonMobil Corporation, is facing another headache over its Natuna D-Alpha working contract as BP Migas (the upstream oil and gas regulatory body) urge the company to immediately submit the feasibility study for the development of Natuna's 173 trillion standard cubic feet (TCF) of natural gas.
ExxonMobil is awaiting the settlement of its years of dispute with Indonesia's PT Pertamina over the giant Cepu oil and gas field in Java Island. Politians mounts pressures on government to appoint Pertamina as the operator of Cepu project.
On September 2005, BP Migas threatened to cancel Exxon's working rights for Natuna D-Alpha amid uncertainty over its future development.
Natuna gas field was estimated to hold total reserves of 140 trillion cubic feet (tcf), though some 72 percent of the reserves contain carbon dioxide. Without the CO2 the gas reserves should be around 45 TCF, which is still huge.
Under such circumstances, the development of Natuna D-Alpha needs investment up to US$40 billion. Such a huge development cost calls for a market capable of generating an adequate return.
That's why, Indonesian government had given the owners of the block the right to retain 40 percent of the block's future gas output, while under standard production sharing contracts, contractors keep 30 percent of gas output, with the remaining 70 percent going to the government.
The D-Alpha block is 74 percent owned by ExxonMobil Oil Indonesia. Pertamina holds the remaining 26 percent of the block. D-Alpha was part of the Natuna gas fields discovered in 1973, located in Natuna Sea, about 225 km off east Natuna Island (600 km northeast of Singapore, and 1,100 km north of Jakarta).
ExxonMobil signed an agreement with the government in 1995 for a 10 year of commercial operation. The fields have never been in production following the failure in the drilling in a number of locations since 1995, but both Exxon and Pertamina still conduct marketing activities and study. Exxon got contract extension for two years that would mature early 2007.
Pertamina has been frustrated by the marketing problem for Natuna D-Alpha and planned to divest 13 percent of its shares to Malaysia's Petronas in exchange of Petronas being the off-taker. In fact, Petronas, Pertamina, and ExxonMobil signed a memorandum of understanding on March 18, 2002 to jointly develop the block.
Three years ago, hopes also emerged as a couple of businessmen brought together by the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) planned to build a pipeline project touted to be the longest undersea gas pipeline in the world linking Natuna D-Alpha, Natuna Island and Shanghai, China. The 4,875-km long pipeline would be routed via Vietnam, Malaysia, and Thailand. However the US$8 billion pipeline project is yet to receive official endorsement from China and Indonesia.
In June 2005, Executive VP Corporate Strategy and Development PTT Public Company Limited (Thailand) Tevin Vongvanich met energy minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro to express the company's interest in developing Natuna D-Alpha.
Purnomo said that time that since there is already a gas pipeline from Natuna (West Natuna fields operated by Conoco), it would make sense if PTT also join the Natuna D-Alpha. But no information since then.
Exxon's partner, Pertamina, decided to postpone the D-Alpha project last year due to huge investment cost. It's a hell of a strain for Exxon.

Labels: , , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Monday, February 27, 2006

Cepu Debacle and the legacy for 2009

As the negotiation clock ticked down to injury time, no immediate signal that ExxonMobil Corporation and Indonesia's Pertamina has reached an agreement over who should operate the giant Cepu oil and gas field. Vice President Jusuf Kalla set the dealine last week for both companies to resolve the dispute by this week at the last and if they failed to do so, government will takeover the appointment. Kalla assigned two ministers, energy and state-owned enterprises, to make decision immediately afterwards.
But it seems that without the president's decision no such deal would materialize. The president is in a South East Asia tour to three countries starting today with Brunei, and then Cambodia and Myanmar. Coordinating minister for the economy Dr Boediono is also on board.
In the absence of president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono and Dr Boediono, it's almost certain that no decision would be made in the next few days on Cepu settlement. The president is scheduled to return home on March 2nd.
Rumors: The President is not comfortable with the fact that Golkar guys have been actively involved in Cepu project. Golkar executive Surya Paloh had secured a deal with Bojonegoro Regency to participate in the administration's share (4.5% in the 10% participating interest for local administrations). Other Golkar figures are believed to had already got the deal with Blora Regency (2.5% split) even though the regent is a PDI-P cadre. With up to 170,000 barrel per day at peak production, Cepu Block could generate trillions of rupiah to local administrations shortly after commercial operation started.
On top of that, VP Kalla is the chairman of Golkar. His statements 10 days ago indicates that Kalla hands on the settlement more than anybody in the cabinet. The president simply don't want to be perceived in public just like the Aceh Peace Deal.
The president is bussy calculating the impact to local politics in Bojonegoro in particular and East Java as a whole towards the 2009 election. He want to make sure that people in Bojonegoro, Blora, Central Java and East Java acknowledge his leadership in resolving the four-year dispute and a settlement could prosper people in these regions. He needs a legacy for 2009.
It is true that Blora and Bojonegoro are small regencies in terms of population. Blora with less than 1 million, while Bojonegoro slightly above 1.2 million people. But a Cepu settlement, with the hope that by 2008 it could start commercial production would also means the success for Central Java and East Java, two of the most populous provinces in Indonesia. SBY lost Central Java to Megawati Soekarnoputri in the 2004 election, and he is surely work hard to win the province in 2009.
Let's do the math. First on schedule. The sooner the decision to operate the block would be better. Let say the construction and preparation would take 36 months, if the project starts next month, the first drop of oil could be in early 2009, months ahead of the election. But local administrations would not get the windfall until the end of the year. Whoever operate the block, it takes few months or even years to reach peak production. But at least, the US$2.5 billion investment had been injected into the local economy by then and thousands of jobs created with the multiplier effects.
Imagine if the project was started last year, right after Exxon and Pertamina signed the Production Sharing Contract with BP Migas in October. The first drop of oil could be before the end of 2008, give room to local administrations to start enjoying the windfall (both through 10% participating interest or the budget arrangement at 15% of the total government's revenue stream) by early 2009, months before the election.
With daily production of 170,000 barrel of oil at US$60 per barrel, total revenue from Cepu would be US$10.2 million per day and it translates to US$3.72 billion per year. Mathematically, government will get US$3.16 billion, Pertamina at US$251 million, Exxon US$251 million, and local administrations US$56 million.
Under the autonomy and oil and gas laws, local administrations should get 15% of government's revenue. Let's say that the government's net revenue after cost recovery would be US$2.5 billion a year. That means, local administrations will get US$375 million to be divided to Bojonegoro and Blora as producing regencies (depending on where the location of the wells drilled in a particular year) at US$162 million, and the rest to other areas in East Java and Central Java.

Labels: , , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, January 14, 2006

Indonesia oil reserves increased slightly 2005

Indonesia's oil reserves increased slightly in 2005 by 134.6 million barrels from the early year at 8.17 billion barrels. Proved reserves, meanwhile, was only 4.187 billion barrels, down from 4.3 billion barrels in 2004.
According to the data released by Indonesia's Upstream Oil and Gas Regulatory Body (BP Migas), even though the working areas increased significantly by 32% last year, the oil discovery was relatively small.
Oil production average at 1.061 million barrel per day (bpd) was also below the target of 1.075 million barrel per day. Mature and depleted oil fields contributed to almost 88% of the total output. With natural production reduction from these depleted fields at 5% to 15% per year and without significant new discoveries, Indonesia's oil output would further decrease in the coming years.
Meanwhile Indonesia's crude oil export reached 157.51 million barrels lasy year, decreased significantly from 178.87 million barrels in 2004. The country imported 126.18 million barrels of crude oil in 2005, also decreased significantly from 148.49 million barrels in 2004.

Labels:


READ MORE!!!

Friday, November 25, 2005

Cepu conflict is getting silly

In the last few days, top executives of state-owned oil and gas company PT Pertamina stated repeatedly that it would drill giant Cepu oil wells straight early next year should the negotiation with ExxonMobil fail to resolve the dispute on operatorship (who operate the block).
Petroleum engineers and those who are familiar with oilfield operation might found such statements as ridiculous. In fact, the president of Pertamina, Mr Widya Purnama, is an electronic engineer, who has limited knowledge about oil and gas operations. But he is a die hard type of leader.
Pertamina is frustrated with the situation that energy department rejects its proposal to have rotating system applied in the project. Today, Widya said that Pertamina would start drilling 40 oil wells in Cepu by February 2006 with investment up to US$120 million. It is too bad that fellow journalists failed to digest what's wrong with the statement.
Technically, you don't have to be a petroleum engineer to understand, no way that Pertamina could drill oil wells by February, while it takes months even to prepare the paperworks. They would need few more months to lay the pipelines in the ground if they're lucky to get faster clearance on land permits.
Even if they could do that in three months, wait a minute, is it legal in the first place?
Pertamina and Exxon signed the Cooperation Contract (KKS) with Upstream Oil and Gas Regulator (BP Migas) in October. If Pertamina move on with the drill straight strategy, what might be the respond from BP Migas, local administrations, residents?
How about Exxon? Well, as the KKS is a legal binding document, BP Migas almost unlikely to let Pertamina drill the oil wells without consent from Exxon. If they do that, Cepu project would end up in international arbitrary like previous high-profile cases i.e. Karaha Bodas and Cemex.
The oil and gas block in East Java is co-owned by Pertamina, Exxon, and a company to be established by local administrations with share ownership of 45%, 45%, and 10% respectively. The block has more than 700 million barrels of oil reserves (some even predicted 1 billion barrels). At peak, Cepu could produce 170,000 bpd. But commercial production is pending on negotiation on operatorship. Exxon claimed it has been appointed as the operator through the memorandum of understanding (MoU) signed in June by Martiono Hadianto (President Commissioner of Pertamina), Aburizal Bakrie (Chief Economic Minister), and Exxon.
Martiono was the leader of government-sponsored Negotiation Team consisted of Iin Arifin Takhyan (director general for oil and gas at the energy department), Umar Said (Pertamina commissioner), Mustiko Saleh (vice president director Pertamina), Lin Che Wei (then expert staff for minister of state-owned enterprises), Roes Aryawijaya (deputy minister SOE), Rizal Malarangeng and M. Ikhsan (expert staffs at the chief economic minister office).
But look at how these guys easily change their minds. I support the nationalism sentiment on the issue. But I hate people without principles. These guys should have fight all the way through the MoU and KKS, but if they had agreed on something, stick to it. The leaders should ask team members whether they agree or disagree before striking a deal with third party like Exxon.
What we have now, conflicting statements between Pertamina executives and between ministers, is just make things worse for all of us. No way we could be a core nation with such periphery mentality. Oh, poor Indonesian.
It is mentality driving a man on to perfection and forcing him to utilize all knowledge in the loving service of his race.

Labels: , , ,


READ MORE!!!

Saturday, November 19, 2005

No more whys, hows please!

Friday, November 18, I attended a panel discussion at Bandung Institute of Technology (ITB) organized by Indonesian Petroleum Engineers Association (IATMI). I missed the opening session (normally ceremonial) but as predicted nothing was so special from Energy Minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro's speech. Anyway, Kun Kurnely, president director of Pertamina EP (Pertamina's sub-holding for exploration and production business) is the chairman of IATMI.
The title of the discussion was Increasing Indonesia's Oil Production with four panelists. They were Novian M. Thaib (from Directorate general for oil and gas), Trijana (BP Migas, Up-Stream Oil and Gas Regulator), Bur Maras (legislator from Partai Demokrat), TN Mahmud (former Mobil Indonesia CEO), and Karsani Aulia (CEO of JOB Pertamina-Bumi Siak Pusako).
The three and a half hour discussion was designed to answer two major questions: Why Indonesia's oil production declined and how to raise that. To be frank, the discussion could be cut-short to one our only as most of the audience (my presumption) were aware of the first question on why. The first-four panelists repeated over and over the why issue with almost similar answers, most of them had been appeared in newspapers.
For almost two-hours of 10-minute each (expanded to 20-minute each), I keep complaining to my friend of how inefficient the way the panelists deliver their key messages. If I may make the score, 9 out of 10 of time available was used to explain the why. Poor research, hefty bureaucrazy, autonomy euphoria, legal uncertainty, depleting reserves, financing difficulties, etc. (I would list down the complete answer on this why later on).
Panelists agree on one-thing; Indonesia is in emergency situation to boost exploration activities. Key target: 1.3 million barrel per day by 2009. Some optimistic the target would be reached, provided that the giant Cepu oilfield (has the potential of 200,000 bpd) could start commercial operation immediately. Others believe the target is not realistic given the gigantic challenges in the industry and the politics.
But how?
Exploration, Exploration, and Exploration! But how to boost exploration activities? Most of panelists believed that Indonesia should attract foreign oil giants. Give them more incentives? Nope! High crude oil price inherently already an incentive, right? They won't come. So what?
One panelist proposed Indonesia Incorporation, the idea many people might think a mere dream. But he insist that Indonesia is not simply in the giant's portfolio anymore. "We are in the seller's market situation. The oil giants wouldn't come to a lesser attractive places like Indonesia. They have too many options at the moment. We shouldn't wait for them to come. We should start by ourselves," he said.
He elaborated further of how the Indonesia Incorporated should work. Government, universities and research institutes conduct the geological studies and exploration. Once they find oil reserve, open the bid to investors.
But such activities need a lot of money, right? Well, government could allocate, let say US$200 million out of its tens of billions oil and gas income for research and exploration.
For sure, it's going to take few more years should Indonesia adopt the idea. The fastest way, for sure, is to start immediately the Cepu block. But how?
Some panelists said it would be better and realistic to appoint ExxonMobil as the operator. They said implementing the rotating system would be stupid thing, ilogical, and applicable only for those who don't understand the petroleum activity.
How about a joint operatorship like in the form of Joint Operating Body (JOB) implemented by Pertamina with other oil and gas contractors?
"That is an ideal concept, but experience taught us that none of Pertamina's JOB works well as Pertamina simply put its people without financing support on the investment," said a BP Migas officer.
Go East, one panelist said. Easter part of Indonesia is underdeveloped. "But nobody would Go East if no basic data available. Provide the accurate basic data first," said other panelist.
Who should make the data available?

Labels: , ,


READ MORE!!!